High Dividend Yields and Superior Returns

Another favourite value-based criterion for choosing stocks is dividend yields.

More recent studies by James O'Shaughnessy have shown that from the period 1951-1996, the 50 highest dividend-yielding stocks had a 1.5% higher annual return among large capitalization stocks.

In another study, a strategy based on the highest yielding stocks in the DJIA outperformed the market.

The correlation between the dividend yield and return can be explained in part by taxes. Stocks with higher dividend yields must offer higher before-tax returns to compensate shareholders for the tax differences.

It should also be noted that most current studies, like O'Shaughnessy's, exclude utility stocks, which as a group have by far the highest dividend yield but have vastly underperformed the market over the past decade.

(Another point to note: for a stock that is paying fixed dividend, the high dividend yield reflects a lower price of the stock and a low dividend yield reflects a higher price of the stock. Therefore, dividend yield fluctuates along a range. Dividend yield can be usefully employed as another tool for valuing the stock.)