Growing with growth stocks

Growing with growth stocks

Tags: Ang Kok Heng

Written by Ang Kok Heng
Monday, 27 July 2009 00:26

AXIATA Group Bhd, formerly TM International Bhd (6888), will cap capital expenditure (capex) at RM4.4 billion this year, in a move to cut costs amid a slowdown in the region's economies. "There are a few things we are doing given the economic situation — we are reducing capex from RM5.4 billion to RM4.4 billion, re-looking all operating costs and benchmarking ourselves to know where we stand," Axiata president and managing director Datuk Seri Jamaludin Ibrahim said.

Malaysia's third-placed mobile operator DiGi Telecommunications is planning to spend more than RM1.1 billion (US$318.9 million) in 2009, Reuters reports.

PPB GROUP BHD [] is planning to spend RM293 million on capex this year, its chairman Datuk Oh Siew Nam said. He said the group's flour-making subsidiary FFM Bhd, has been allocated RM173 million to build new flour mills in Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, and Jakarta, Indonesia.

Food-based QL RESOURCES BHD [] has earmarked RM280 million as capex for its current fiscal year and the next, deemed pivotal to spur its regional merger and acquisition (M&A) plans, and to improve its manufacturing facilities. Some RM130 million and RM150 million are allocated for the financial years (FY) ending March 2010 and 2011, respectively.

TA ANN HOLDINGS BHD [] plans to spend up to RM189 million in 2009, with most of the money going into oil palm PLANTATION []s, group managing director and chief executive officer Datuk Wong Kuo Hea said

TOMEI CONSOLIDATED BHD [] has budgeted about RM10 million for capex this year in a bid to expand amid the economic slowdown, the jeweller's group managing director Ng Yih Pyng said. "The amount allocated will be used mainly for our outlet expansion and also to improve our information TECHNOLOGY [] (IT) system," he told StarBiz in an interview.

Top Glove Corp Bhd chairman Tan Sri Dr Lim Wee-Chai said the group had allocated some RM80 million for capex, which would include organic expansion and potential acquisitions. TENAGA NASIONAL BHD []'s capex this year amounted to RM3.75 billion to RM4 billion, lower than RM4.5 billion previously. UMW HOLDINGS BHD [] plans some RM600 million in capex this year to beef up its oil and gas (O&G) business, according to managing director and chief executive officer Datuk Dr Abdul Halim Harun.

The capex planned by companies is mainly for future expansion. It is this capex that generates business and hence earnings growth for a company. Earnings growth is the main attraction in equity investment.

Stock grows
One of the main duties of the management is to grow the company. When a company is operating at full capacity, additional capex is needed to grow the earnings. The funds for capex could be internally generated or from borrowed capital. This type of reinvestment is the yearly expansion budget of a company. Every incremental investment will provide additional return which will add to the existing profit of a company.

Some companies may be faced with diminishing return which occurs when profitability falls over time either because of more competition or less lucrative investment return. So long as the return on investment (ROI) is higher than the bank's interest rates, there is value added from the expansion plan.

But the ROI of most investments is expected to be much higher than the bank's interest rates since every investment comes with a certain amount of risk. When ROI is substantially higher than borrowing rates, it will make sense to borrow to enhance business returns. Every capex may be viewed individually from the ROI point of view such that the return must be worth the effort and risk taken. In many cases, the return may not be immediate and some may even suffer losses for the initial few years before profit starts to flow in.


Growth stocks pay less dividends
Because of the need to grow, growth stocks normally pay less on dividends so that a larger portion of the profit is retained for future expansion. The amount of dividend paid to shareholders as a percentage of the profit is known as dividend payout ratio. The dividend payout of a growth stock could be less than 50% while some may be as low as 20%.

Generally, a stock with low dividend payout and low dividend yield is expected to have higher earnings growth. On the other hand, a stock with high dividend payout and thus high dividend yield has lower earnings growth. In this way, growth stocks tend to have higher price appreciation than high-dividend yield stocks.

It is not uncommon to come across management's explanation to its shareholders on the reasons for keeping some of the profit for future expansion. As every company has its own expansion plans, the company usually conserves some cash for future use and pay the balance to shareholders. In this way, there is no need to raise money from shareholders via rights issues for expansion purposes.

In certain cases, although the company may post profit, it may not have sufficient free cashflow to pay dividend, as the profit is just an "accounting profit". In this case, the "profit" is tied up in inventories or receivables and hence it cannot be paid to shareholders. A good company is one which can pay relatively high dividends and yet able to continue to provide reasonable growth.

More capex, higher growth
There are also many listed companies which did not pay high dividends and yet their earnings growth was mediocre. If the capex is not well spent, the earnings growth may not be forth coming. Although failed projects may not be entirely the fault of the management, a good manager should also avoid or minimise such losses.

More importantly bad investment should not be repeated. Unfortunately, it is not uncommon to see several companies listed on Bursa Malaysia which did not seem to get any of their investment strategies right year after year. The poor ROE (return on equity or shareholders' fund) in the past and non-improvement in ROE over the years prove the failures of the management to deliver basic economic profit to shareholders.

At the beginning of this article, several companies disclosed their capex requirements for the year. For a growth stock, the capex is likely to be higher relatively to its size. For the selected companies, we have listed them in Table 1. We have divided the capex by market capitalisation (a measure of value of a company) and also by fixed assets. Although these ratios may not be conclusive to determine which stock is a better growth stock, they provide some ideas on the expansion plans.



It should be noted that the low capex of a company in a particular year may not necessarily denote lower earnings growth going forward. It could be due to the adequate capacity for the time being or less need to expand due to the prevailing market conditions. Some companies may not be capital intensive and hence less need to spend as much.

Expansion path
Listed companies have many options to grow. They can grow organically through natural expansion or by way of acquisition. The growth can be financed by internally generated funds, borrowing or a combination of both. They may also issue new shares to acquire the target company or call for rights issues to finance the expansion (see Chart 1).



It is not uncommon for a company to move downstream by adding value to what it produces, for example, to process its products further. It can also go upstream to procure its own raw materials so as to be in a better position to control its supplies. A company facing limited growth in its existing business may also venture into new businesses to remain relevant. This type of diversification can also be useful to stabilise the cyclical business nature of a company.

Capital gain can be volatile
From an investor's perspective, the ROI is the dividend income received regularly and the capital gain from price appreciation.

For a high-dividend stock, the dividend yield is similar to assured return received, say 4% per annum. The capital gain, normally smaller for a high- dividend stock, is like a bonus on top of the dividend.

For growth stock, the dividend yield is smaller (see Chart 2) and capital gain is what an investor mainly aims for. Unfortunately, capital gain can be very volatile, since the share price could be influenced by market sentiment. Furthermore, as the business risk of a high-growth company is normally higher, the expected price appreciation will depend on the results of the expansion plan. Most investments provide both income and capital gain. Examples are unit trusts, bonds, PROPERTIES [] and foreign currencies.



There are also several investments which do not provide income. These are merely trading instruments. They include commodity trading, gold and similar types of commodity which bet purely on the price appreciation. Investors who "invest" in gold thinking that this is a good investment, must bear in mind that gold does not provide income, it only provides capital gain (or speculative gain). A kilogramme of gold remains a kilo after several years. A growth stock (provided it is a true growth stock and not speculative stock), on the other hand, will grow over time and will not be the same after several years.

Fixed-income instruments don't grow
Most investment grade stocks provide some growth. Even a low-growth high-dividend yield stock may have small growth. If the growth is only 2% per year, the dividend received is also likely to grow by 2% per annum. In this example, assuming the dividend yield is 4% per annum, a 2% growth in dividend will mean that after five years, the dividend yield will increase to 4.4%. As such, growth does make a difference in the return.

In the case of fixed-income instruments such as fixed deposits (FD) with the bank, the FD rate is fixed during the period of placement. If a one-year FD yields 3%, it is 3%. If the interest rate remains the same, the same FD will continue to give 3% return the following year.

While interest rate may go up one year later after the FD matures, it may possibly go down as well. There is no growth factor in FD placement. Some may argue that the growth in savings from interest rate is compounding. The compounding effect by reinvesting the interest earned is similar to the compounding effect achieved by reinvesting the dividend earned in the case of investing in a high-yield stock which may still provide some growth.

Some stocks don't grow
While investing in FD is a constant yield investment, there are also many stocks which don't grow over time. Unfortunately, the earnings of many stocks listed on Bursa Malaysia are very sluggish and they don't seem to increase even after ten years. It is a disappointing fact. These companies remain more or less the same after one or two rounds of the economic cycle. They seem to struggle with the same business year in year out.

Investing in non-growth stocks is like investing in FD with the same yield. The only difference is that non-growth stocks usually do not provide high dividend as they are not well-managed and hence their operating cashflow may not be stable. The lack of confidence to generate sufficient and consistent cashflow prevents these companies from paying higher dividend.

Some stocks degrade like their retiring owners
One of the reasons why some companies degrade and show stagnant earnings is the lost of drive (the oomph!) when the key promoters retire or on the verge of retiring. The lack of successors either among the owners' scion or from other professionals could not propel the companies forward. In some cases, the children who took over the businesses were not as capable as the founders were. As a result, these successors acted merely like a caretaker. Not only were they not able to grow the business, some of them were not even able to defend the companies' market shares.

Investing in non-growth stocks is already bad, investing in negative-growth stocks is even worst.

Investment provides yields and capital gains
In short, investment provides yields and capital gains. Some investments like FD provide pure yields but no growth at all. Some investments like gold and commodities only provide capital gains but not income. Pure capital gain investment is more speculative in nature and is not suitable for the buy-and-hold strategy. Trading strategy is more appropriate for this type of investment and market timing is crucial. Many other investments provide both yield and capital gain.

Yields are like a bird in hand and capital gains are like birds in the bushes. Some capital gains are easier to anticipate, while some capital gains are less predictive.

Ang has 20 years' experience in research and investment. He is currently the chief investment officer of Phillip Capital Management Sdn Bhd.


http://www.theedgemalaysia.com/business-news/129607-growing-with-growth-stocks.html