The Investment Policies based on Benjamin Graham.

 The Investment Policies based on Benjamin Graham.

Elaboration of Section 1

This section is the cornerstone of the entire article, establishing the fundamental philosophy that guides all subsequent advice. It is based directly on the work of Benjamin Graham, the father of value investing and the intellectual mentor of Warren Buffett.

The core of this section can be broken down into three critical concepts:

1. The Categorization of Investment Policies
Graham doesn't believe in a one-size-fits-all approach. Instead, he provides a clear menu of options based on an investor's goals. The policies are structured from most conservative to most aggressive:

• Policy A: Investment for Fixed Income: This is the safest tier, focused entirely on capital preservation. It includes instruments like fixed deposits (FDs) and government bonds. The primary goal is safety, not growth.

• Policy B: Investment for Income & Moderate Appreciation: This tier introduces a balance. It aims for a reasonable income (e.g., dividends) and some protection against inflation. This is achieved through:

  • Investment Funds: Diversified mutual funds or unit trusts.

  • Blue-Chip Stocks: Shares of large, well-established, and financially sound companies, but only when bought at a "reasonable price."

• Policy C: Investment Chiefly for Profit: This is for investors seeking higher returns and who are willing to do more work. It outlines several "enterprising" approaches:

  • Buying general stocks when the overall market is low.

  • Buying growth stocks at a reasonable price relative to their current performance (not future hype).

  • Value Investing: The core Graham strategy—buying securities that are selling for significantly less than their intrinsic value (a "bargain").

  • Buying high-grade bonds and preferred shares.

  • Exploiting "special situations" like mergers or arbitrage.

• Policy D: Speculation: Graham is very clear to distinguish this from investing. Speculation includes:

  • Buying IPOs (new ventures).

  • Active trading.

  • Buying "growth stocks" at inflated, "generous" prices. He warns that this should be done with a separate pool of money one can afford to lose.

2. The Two Types of Investors: Defensive vs. Enterprising
This is a psychological and practical classification, not one based on wealth.

• The Defensive Investor: This investor seeks safety and freedom from effort. Graham includes in this category people who lack the time (e.g., a busy professional) or the inclination to deeply analyze investments. Their strategy should be simple and safe, sticking to Policy A and B.

• The Enterprising (or Aggressive) Investor: This investor is willing to devote significant time and "intelligent effort" to the task of investing. They have the interest and temperament to research and analyze securities. They can pursue the strategies in Policy A, B, and C.

3. The Crucial Difference Between Investment and Speculation
This is the most important philosophical point in the section. Graham provides a precise, three-part definition:

"An INVESTMENT OPERATION is one which, upon THOROUGH ANALYSIS, promises SAFETY OF PRINCIPAL and a SATISFACTORY RETURN. Operations NOT meeting these requirements are speculative."

Let's break down the definition:

• Thorough Analysis: This means a detailed, fact-based study of the asset, not a tip from a friend or a gut feeling.

• Safety of Principal: The primary goal is to not lose your initial capital. The investment must have a low risk of permanent loss.

• Satisfactory Return: The return should be reasonable and aligned with the level of risk. It doesn't have to be spectacular.

Graham adds that an investment must be justifiable on both qualitative and quantitative grounds (the nature of the business and its numbers) and that price is always a critical factor. A great company can be a terrible investment if you pay too much for it.

He concludes by distinguishing speculation from gambling:

• Intelligent Speculation: Taking a calculated risk after careful study of the pros and cons.

• Unintelligent Speculation: Taking a risk without any real analysis.

• Gambling: Creating a risk that didn't exist before (e.g., betting on a horse race).

---

Summary of Section 1

Section 1 lays the foundational philosophy for intelligent investing by defining clear policies, investor profiles, and the critical line between investing and speculation.

• Investment Policies: It outlines a spectrum of strategies, from safe fixed-income (Policy A) to more profitable but riskier value and growth investing (Policy C), while clearly labeling speculation (Policy D) as a separate, dangerous activity.

• Investor Profiles: It distinguishes between the Defensive Investor, who should adopt a simple, low-effort strategy focused on safety, and the Enterprising Investor, who can pursue higher returns through active analysis and strategies like value investing.

• Core Definition: The section's most vital lesson is Graham's definition of an investment operation: it must be based on thorough analysis, prioritize safety of principal, and only then seek a satisfactory return. Any activity failing to meet these three criteria is considered speculation.

In essence, this section teaches you to first know who you are as an investor (Defensive or Enterprising), then choose an appropriate strategy from Graham's menu, and finally, to always ensure your actions qualify as true investment and not speculation. This disciplined framework is the first and most important step toward managing risk and achieving long-term financial success.

May your investing be happy, safe and profitable over the long term.

May your investing be happy, safe and profitable over the long term

Elaboration of Section 33

This section is the concluding summary and final send-off for the entire HSK72 investment guide. It serves three primary purposes: to recap the immense journey, to distill its ultimate lesson, and to offer a heartfelt wish for the reader's future.

1. The Grand Recap: A Review of the 33-Section Journey
The author begins by systematically reviewing all the topics covered, dividing them into two main parts for clarity. This serves as a final checklist and a powerful reminder of the comprehensive ground covered.

• Part 1 (Sections 1-11): The Philosophical and Strategic Foundation. This part established the "why" and the "what" of intelligent investing, covering core texts, self-assessment, asset allocation, diversification, risk, and the stories of successful investors.

• Part 2 (Sections 12-32): The Practical Application and Execution. This part delved into the "how," moving from theory to practice with stock selection (QMV), valuation, portfolio management, behavioral finance, and specific product analysis.

2. The Single Most Important Question
After this extensive journey through complex analysis and strategy, the conclusion brings everything into sharp focus with one critical, guiding question that must be asked before any investment is made:

"FIRSTLY, does this ensure safety of my capital (is this safe) and then only ask, what is the potential return."

This is the ultimate takeaway. It is a direct echo of Benjamin Graham's Rule #1 and the core of the intelligent investing philosophy. All the tools, worksheets, and frameworks (QMV, Margin of Safety, etc.) are ultimately in service of answering this one question affirmatively.

3. The Path to Mastery: The 10,000-Hour Rule
The section ends on a note of both encouragement and realism. It acknowledges that achieving true expertise requires deep study, humorously referencing the "10,000 hours" of practice popularized by Malcolm Gladwell. This tells the reader that while the guide provides the essential map and tools, the journey of lifelong learning continues.

4. The Final Blessing
The document closes as it began, with a warm and personal wish for the reader's success, once again invoking the benchmark of Warren Buffett: "Once again, may your investing be as successful as Buffett's."

---

Summary of Section 33

Section 33 is the concluding chapter that synthesizes the entire HSK72 guide, reiterating that the ultimate goal of intelligent investing is to prioritize the safety of capital above all else, using the comprehensive framework provided to achieve long-term, profitable results.

• Comprehensive Journey: The guide has provided a complete education, from the foundational philosophy of Graham to the practical tools of stock analysis and portfolio management.

• The Golden Rule: The single most important principle to carry forward is to always first ask: "Is my capital safe?" before considering potential returns.

• A Lifelong Pursuit: Mastering these principles is a long-term endeavor requiring continuous learning and application.

• The Final Wish: The ultimate goal is for the reader to apply this knowledge to build a happy, safe, and profitable financial future.

In essence, this final section transforms the collection of notes from a mere information dump into a coherent philosophy with a clear, overriding purpose. It ensures the reader walks away not with a head full of disjointed tips, but with a disciplined, safety-first mindset that will guide every investment decision for years to come.

Additional notes: a collection of advanced insights and clarifications, focusing on the specific opportunities, pitfalls, and mindset of the enterprising investor.

 Additional Notes.

Elaboration of Section 32

This section serves as a valuable appendix, offering a collection of nuanced insights, clarifications, and advanced considerations that build upon the core principles already established. It provides deeper color to the philosophy of the intelligent, enterprising investor.

The notes cover several key themes:

1. Refining the Enterprising Investor's Approach
The section begins by reiterating that the enterprising investor should start with a defensive base (high-grade stocks and bonds) and only then branch out into more opportunistic strategies. It emphasizes that these departures must be "well-reasoned."

It then provides a list of negative prescriptions—things the enterprising investor should generally avoid:

• Avoid low-yielding corporate bonds.

• Avoid inferior bonds and preferred stocks unless they are true bargains (at least 30% below par).

• Avoid foreign government bonds.

• Be wary of new issues (IPOs) and other "tempting" new financial instruments.

2. Sources of Opportunity for the Enterprising Investor
The notes outline the specific market conditions where an enterprising investor can find "attractive buying opportunities." These arise from discrepancies between price and value due to:

• A low general market level (e.g., during a bear market).

• Extreme unpopularity of a specific stock (e.g., a good company facing a temporary, solvable scandal).

• The market's failure to recognize a company's improvement.

• Complex corporate situations that hide true value, which "competent security analysis" can unravel.

3. The Evolution from Graham to Buffett
A crucial historical insight is offered: while Benjamin Graham's primary focus was on buying statistical bargains (his "Strategy 4"), he actually made the bulk of his personal fortune from a single, long-term investment in a wonderful company—GEICO (a "Strategy 3" investment).

• The Implication: If Graham had lived longer, he might have placed even greater emphasis on buying and holding wonderful businesses at fair prices, a strategy his most famous student, Warren Buffett, perfected.

4. Warnings on Advisors and Market Structure
The section includes sharp warnings about the investment industry:

• Be critical of free advice from friends and relatives, as "much bad advice is given free."

• Understand the broker's conflict of interest: The stock market thrives on speculation, and brokers make money from activity. A truly professional, client-centric brokerage would have to advise trading less, which is not in its commercial interest.

5. The Mindset of the Successful Investor
The notes conclude with powerful mindset takeaways:

• For a mature portfolio, the substantial dividend income can far exceed any potential gains from short-term trading, making the portfolio resilient to market downturns.

• The ultimate strategy is to be "fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful," using market crises as opportunities to buy great businesses at discounted prices.

• The critical distinction between timing (speculative forecasting) and pricing (the intelligent assessment of value) is reiterated. The intelligent investor focuses exclusively on the latter.

---

Summary of Section 32

Section 32 provides a collection of advanced insights and clarifications, focusing on the specific opportunities, pitfalls, and mindset of the enterprising investor.

• Refined Strategy: The enterprising investor must have a well-reasoned justification for any move away from a defensive base and should avoid a specific list of generally poor investment types.

• Sources of Profit: The key is to find discrepancies between price and value caused by market pessimism, neglect, or complexity.

• Historical Context: The strategy of buying and holding wonderful companies (Buffett's approach) proved more lucrative even for the father of value investing, Benjamin Graham.

• Industry Warnings: Investors must be wary of conflicts of interest in the financial industry and unsolicited advice.

• The Winning Mindset: Success comes from a focus on pricing rather than timing, embracing market fear, and building a portfolio where sustainable dividend income ultimately outweighs the noise of short-term trading.

In essence, this section adds the final layer of sophistication to the intelligent investing philosophy, moving from the "what" and "how" to the nuanced "when" and "why," while reinforcing the discipline required to be truly successful.

SUMMARY OF A SOUND INVESTMENT POLICY (BENJAMIN GRAHAM & QMV METHOD).

 SUMMARY OF A SOUND INVESTMENT POLICY (BENJAMIN GRAHAM & QMV METHOD).

Elaboration of Section 31

This section serves as a powerful recap and synthesis, bringing the entire discussion full circle. It consolidates the foundational wisdom from the beginning with the practical framework developed throughout the document. It's designed to be a quick-reference guide for the intelligent investor.

The summary is structured in two clear parts:

Part 1: The Foundational Policies of Benjamin Graham (A Direct Reprise of Section 1)
This part reiterates the core menu of strategies from Benjamin Graham, reminding the investor of the different paths available based on their goals and temperament.

• Policy A: Investment for Fixed Income. The safest tier, for capital preservation (e.g., FDs, bonds).

• Policy B: Investment for Income & Moderate Appreciation. A balanced approach using investment funds and blue-chip stocks for income and some growth.

• Policy C: Investment Chiefly for Profit. The enterprising investor's path. This includes:

  • Buying in low markets.

  • Buying growth stocks at reasonable prices.

  • VALUE INVESTING: Buying securities below intrinsic value.

  • Special situations (arbitrage, etc.).

• Policy D: Speculation. Clearly labeled as a separate, high-risk activity (IPOs, trading, overpaying for growth).

This is then mapped directly to the two investor profiles:

• Defensive Investor: Should stick to Portfolio A & B.

• Enterprising Investor: Can pursue Portfolio A, B, & C.

Part 2: The Practical Execution Framework (The KISS Strategy from Section 6)
This part summarizes the actionable, day-to-day methodology for implementing the policies above, particularly for the enterprising investor following Policy C.

It condenses the process into two easy-to-remember acronyms:

• For BUYING, remember "ABC":

  • Assess Quality, Management, and Valuation (QMV).

  • Buy only good quality stocks.

  • Buy at a Conservative price (Margin of Safety).

• For SELLING, remember "1, 2, 3, 4":

  • 1. (To be avoided) Need cash for an emergency.

  • 2. (Urgent - Defensive) The company's fundamentals have permanently deteriorated. SELL.

  • 3. (Offensive) The stock is significantly overvalued.

  • 4. (Offensive) You found a much better bargain.

The selling strategy is further refined into:

• Defensive Portfolio Management (Reason 2): Aimed at preventing harm. This is urgent.

• Offensive Portfolio Management (Reasons 3 & 4): Aimed at optimizing returns. This can be done at leisure.

---

Summary of Section 31

Section 31 is a master summary that combines Benjamin Graham's strategic policies with a simple, actionable framework for making buy and sell decisions, providing a complete blueprint for intelligent investing.

• The Strategic Foundation (Graham's Policies): Defines the spectrum from safe, defensive investing (A & B) to profitable, enterprising investing (C), while clearly isolating speculation (D).

• The Tactical Execution (The KISS Framework): Provides a disciplined, repeatable process:

  • Buy using "ABC": Assess (QMV), Buy (Quality), Conservative (Price).

  • Sell using "1,2,3,4": Based on emergency needs, deteriorating fundamentals, overvaluation, or a better opportunity.

In essence, this section is the ultimate takeaway. It ensures that an investor is never without a guiding principle. They first choose their overarching strategy (Am I defensive or enterprising?) and then apply the simple "ABC" and "1,2,3,4" rules to execute that strategy with discipline. It perfectly captures the document's goal: to provide a sound, business-like philosophy that is also practical and safe to implement.

Know what you are buying – investment products, insurance and mutual funds.

 Know what you are buying – investment products, insurance and mutual funds.

Elaboration of Section 30

This section serves as a crucial consumer protection and due diligence guide. It warns investors to look beyond the marketing name of a financial product and understand its underlying mechanics, costs, and true purpose. The core message is that complexity and opacity are often used to hide poor value.

1. Scrutinizing Investment Products: The "Capital Guaranteed" Trap
The section uses the example of "Capital Guaranteed Funds" to illustrate a common pitfall.

• The Alluring Name: The name suggests absolute safety of your principal.

• The Ugly Reality: Upon investigation, the product structure often reveals that 90% of your capital is invested in safe, low-return government bonds (which actually provide the guarantee), and only 10% is invested in equities.

• The Problem: After accounting for high sales charges and management fees, the potential upside from the tiny equity portion is so minimal that the investor would likely have been better off simply putting their money in a fixed deposit. The lesson is to always look under the hood and understand the asset allocation and fee structure.

2. The Right Role for Insurance: Protection, Not Investment
This part delivers a clear, rule-based distinction:

• Buy Insurance for PROTECTION: The primary purpose of insurance is to cover catastrophic, unforeseen financial losses (e.g., death, critical illness). For this, term insurance is the most efficient and affordable product because it offers pure protection with no investment component.

• Do NOT Buy Insurance for INVESTMENT: Insurance products that combine protection with investment (e.g., endowment, whole life, investment-linked policies) are generally poor investment vehicles. They come with high costs, and the investment returns are often low because the funds are managed ultra-conservatively to meet regulatory and liability requirements. The smart strategy is to "buy term and invest the rest" separately.

3. Selecting Mutual Funds: Philosophy Over Past Performance
When choosing a mutual fund, the section advises looking beyond recent returns and focusing on the manager's core philosophy.

• The Example of Magellan Funds: The section holds up this fund as a model because its stated investment philosophy is a mirror of this entire guide. It explicitly aims to:

  • Minimize the risk of permanent capital loss.

  • Find outstanding companies with wide "economic moats."

  • Buy these companies at a discount to intrinsic value (a Margin of Safety).

• The Due Diligence: This means an intelligent investor should read a fund's prospectus and understand its stated philosophy, ensuring it aligns with sound, business-like investing principles rather than short-term speculation.

4. The Critical Factor of Integrity
The section ends by circling back to a theme from Section 23: the paramount importance of integrity. Judging the integrity of a product provider or fund manager is difficult but essential. A lack of integrity means the seller's interests (to earn fees) are not aligned with your interests (to grow wealth). This is why understanding the product structure and philosophy yourself is a non-negotiable form of self-defense.

---

Summary of Section 30

Section 30 is a practical guide to financial self-defense, warning investors to thoroughly understand any financial product before buying it and to use different products for their intended purposes.

• Investment Products: Look beyond the name. Analyze the underlying structure and fees. Often, "safe" products are structured in a way that offers minimal real return after costs.

• Insurance: Use it for protection only. Buy affordable term insurance for pure financial protection. Avoid using insurance as an investment vehicle, as it is a costly and inefficient way to build wealth.

• Mutual Funds: Judge the philosophy, not just the performance. Select funds whose stated investment philosophy aligns with value investing principles—seeking quality businesses with a margin of safety.

The Overarching Principle: The biggest risk is often buying something you don't understand. Complexity is frequently used to obscure poor value and high costs. The intelligent investor's duty is to perform this due diligence to ensure their capital is deployed efficiently and in alignment with their goals.

Behavioural Finance. The biggest enemy in investing is yourself.

 Behavioural Finance. The biggest enemy in investing is yourself.

Elaboration of Section 29

This section introduces one of the most critical yet overlooked aspects of investing: Behavioral Finance. This field studies how psychological influences and biases cause investors to act irrationally, often to their own severe financial detriment. The central thesis is that your own psychology is a greater threat to your success than any market crash.

1. The Core Concept: The "Party Effect" or Recency Bias
The section uses a powerful allegory, the "Party Effect," to explain a common behavioral bias known as Recency Bias. This is the tendency to weigh recent events more heavily than earlier ones and to extrapolate recent trends into the future indefinitely.

• The Party Scenario: Imagine 30 guests at a party. Each bought the same S&P 500 index fund, but they started investing in consecutive months over a 30-month period.

• The Market Cycle: The first 18 months were a bull market (prices rising 3% per month), followed by 12 months of a bear market (prices falling 2% per month). Over the full 30 months, the fund returned a healthy 12%.

• The Divergent Perspectives:

  • Guest 1 (started 30 months ago): Sees a +12% return. He is content.

  • Guest 10 (started 21 months ago): Sees a +1.36% return. He is disappointed.

  • Guest 19 (started 12 months ago): Sees a -21.53% return. He is panicked and believes the stock market is a terrible place.

  • Guest 25 (started 6 months ago): Sees a -11.42% return. He is fearful.

• The Lesson: All four guests are looking at the exact same investment, but their personal experience (their "recent" history) gives them a completely different, and often incorrect, perception of the market. This bias leads them to make poor decisions—the losing investors are likely to sell in a panic at the worst possible time, while the winners may become overconfident.

2. The Consequences: How Biases Destroy Wealth
Behavioral finance shows that these ingrained biases lead to predictable and costly errors:

• Selling Low and Buying High: Driven by fear (during downturns) and greed (during bubbles).

• Chasing Performance: Buying into hot sectors or funds after they have already seen massive gains, only to be caught in the subsequent crash.

• Overconfidence: Believing you know more than the market, leading to excessive trading and risk-taking.

3. The Solution: Expertise and Self-Awareness
The section concludes that the only way to overcome these powerful psychological traps is through one of two paths:

• Become an Expert Yourself: By deeply understanding how the market works and being aware of your own biases, you can learn to manage your emotions and stick to a disciplined strategy. You recognize market downturns as opportunities, not threats.

• Hire a True Expert (and Be Able to Identify One): If you cannot become an expert, you must find a trustworthy, knowledgeable advisor who can act as a rational guide. However, the section warns that this is difficult if you lack the expertise to judge their competence and integrity in the first place.

4. The Yale University Lecture
The link to the Yale lecture provides an academic foundation for these ideas, covering concepts like:

• Prospect Theory: How people value gains and losses differently, leading to irrational decision-making.

• Overconfidence: The tendency to overestimate one's own knowledge and ability.

---

Summary of Section 29

Section 29 argues that the most dangerous enemy an investor faces is their own psychology, which leads to systematic errors like Recency Bias—the tendency to make decisions based on recent experiences rather than long-term facts.

• The Core Problem: Investors' perceptions are distorted by their personal entry point into the market (the "Party Effect"). This leads to emotionally-driven decisions, such as selling in a panic after recent losses or buying into manias after recent gains.

• The Field of Study: Behavioral Finance explains these irrational but predictable patterns.

• The Ultimate Challenge: You cannot avoid these psychological traps by abdicating responsibility. You must either:

  1. Become an expert to manage your own behavior, or

  2. Develop the expertise to identify and hire a truly competent, ethical advisor to do it for you.

In essence, this section teaches that winning the inner game is a prerequisite for winning the financial game. No amount of financial analysis will help an investor who cannot control their own fear and greed. The intelligent investor must not only analyze companies but also conduct a ruthless self-analysis to overcome the biases that doom the majority to failure.

Compounding, the 8th wonder of the world.

 Compounding, the 8th wonder of the world.

Elaboration of Section 28

This section is dedicated to the single most powerful force in investing: Compound Interest. It is described as the "8th wonder of the world" (a quote often attributed to Einstein), and for good reason. This section illustrates how compounding transforms disciplined saving and time into extraordinary wealth.

1. The Core Mechanism: Earning Returns on Your Returns
Compounding is the process where the earnings generated by an investment themselves generate their own earnings.

• Without Compounding (Simple Interest): You earn returns only on your original principal.

• With Compounding: You earn returns on your original principal plus all the accumulated earnings from previous periods. This creates a snowball effect where growth accelerates dramatically over time.

2. The Mathematical Magic: The Rule of 72
The section introduces the "Rule of 72," a simple formula to estimate the power of compounding:

• Formula: 72 ÷ Annual Interest Rate = Number of years to double your money.

• Examples:

  • At 4%, your money doubles every 18 years (72/4).

  • At 12%, it doubles every 6 years (72/12).

  • At 15%, it doubles every 4.8 years (72/15). This shows why the 15% target from earlier sections is so powerful.

3. The Two Most Critical Ingredients: Rate and Time
The section uses powerful stories to show that compounding requires both a good rate of return and, most importantly, a very long time horizon.

• The Story of Anne Scheiber (Revisited): She started seriously at age 51. By living to 101 and compounding at 15%, her wealth grew exponentially. The retrospective calculation shows that her $22 million fortune was built from a relatively modest sum that doubled again and again over 50 years.

• The Story of Warren Buffett: The section makes a stunning point: 95% of Buffett's wealth was built after his 50th birthday. His skill was the catalyst, but the time he has been investing (over seven decades) provided the fuel for compounding to work its magic on a massive scale. This demonstrates that the biggest gains occur in the later years.

4. The Ultimate Lesson: Start Early and Be Patient
The section hammers home two key messages:

• For the Young: The earlier you start, the less you need to save. The story of Michael vs. Terrence shows that someone who saves for only 10 years early in life can end up with more than someone who saves larger amounts for 25 years starting a decade later.

• For Retirees (The "Oldies"): It's not too late. While the gains won't be as astronomical as Buffett's, the principle still applies. Consistent compounding at a reasonable rate is the most reliable way to grow and protect wealth, even in one's 50s, 60s, and beyond.

---

Summary of Section 28

Section 28 explains that compound interest—earning returns on your returns—is the most powerful force for building wealth, and its effectiveness is determined by the rate of return and, most critically, the length of time invested.

• The "8th Wonder": Compound interest has a snowball effect, where growth accelerates over time, leading to exponential results.

• The Rule of 72: A simple formula to see how long it will take to double your money at a given interest rate.

• The Critical Ingredient is Time: The most significant growth happens in the later years. This is why starting early is paramount, as demonstrated by the fact that the vast majority of Warren Buffett's wealth was built after age 50.

• The Practical Implication: The key to harnessing this power is to start as early as possible, invest consistently, and hold for the very long term, allowing the mathematical inevitability of compounding to work in your favor.

In essence, this section provides the "why" behind the entire long-term, buy-and-hold philosophy promoted throughout this set of notes. It shows that investing success is not about getting rich quickly through speculation, but about getting rich surely through the patient and disciplined application of a mathematical certainty.