Sunday 2 May 2010

External auditors raise red flags at 6 companies

Several accounting firms have raised red flags at six companies yesterday, indicating they could not complete their audits properly.

The companies are Nam Fatt Corp Bhd, Patimas Computers Bhd, Mangotone Group Bhd, Wawasan TKH Holdings Bhd, Luster Industries Bhd and KBB Resources Bhd, based on their announcements to Bursa Malaysia.

Five of them had their accounts qualified, which means that auditors had incomplete information for their work or they may disagree with the company's management on certain assumptions.

However, Luster's auditors, which is Grant Thornton, did not qualify its opinion but pointed out to shareholders that the company's fate rests on an approval by Bursa Malaysia Bhd.

Financially-troubled Luster, a precision plastic parts maker, had submitted its revamp plan on September 18 2009, which was rejected by Bursa on February 11 2010. It appealed on March 4 but Bursa has yet to decide.

Construction group Nam Fatt is also in trouble after it defaulted on some loans and made an operational loss of some RM560 million in the year to December 31 2009.

It has to submit a revamp plan a year from March 15 2010 and it has yet to finalise such a plan.

Accountants from Deloitte & Touche could not find enough audit evidence for doubtful debt provisions while audited accounts of certain subsidiaries were not available.

In this instance, Deloitte said this is in breach of the Companies Act.

In the case of Wawasan TKH, a disposable food packaging maker, its auditors BDO did not agree with the assumptions of its management.

Management thinks that certain assets worth RM83 million should not be impaired, or that the value should not fall, because of assumptions on sales growth of up to 19 per cent and gross profit margins of up to 18 per cent.

"These assumptions by their very nature, are difficult to substantiate given past actual outcomes and are regarded as significant areas of uncertainties," BDO said.

As for Patimas, its auditors do not share the management's optimism that it could recover money from a former subsidiary.

Auditors of Mangotone, which is undergoing a restructuring, could not find enough evidence to support their work while those of KBB were not present during the counting of finished goods at warehouses.

The vermicelli maker did not arrange for the presence of its external auditors during the counting of products worth some RM27 million.

http://www.btimes.com.my/Current_News/BTIMES/articles/redflag/Article/index_html

Related:

8 Signs Of A Doomed Stock

No comments: