Time to let the euro die

Time to let the euro die
May 18, 2010 - 7:10PM

The time for tough decisions is here. In the next few months, the members of the euro area will have to make a choice: create a genuine fiscal and political union or let the euro die a slow death.

The European Union now realizes the Greek crisis has revealed some major flaws in the common currency. There's no point trying to fudge it. The euro can only be rescued by a sweeping centralization of control over tax and spending.

There's just one snag: A single economic government for the euro area isn't going to work. The surrender of national sovereignty is too great. The timing is all wrong. And there is still no realistic mechanism for enforcing whatever new rules are made in Frankfurt or Brussels.

With every step that this crisis takes, the euro moves closer and closer to falling apart. In a few years, we'll be talking again about the deutsche mark, the franc and the peseta.

After dithering for too long, policy makers now recognize that the foundations of the euro weren't strong enough.

The Stability and Growth Pact, which limited budget deficits to 3 per cent of gross domestic product, didn't work. Greece was running fiscal gaps far larger than those during the good years, and plenty of other nations were as well once the global economy turned down. It became a massive free lunch.

Countries could spend like crazy and get their neighbors to bail them out. It was hard to see how the system could survive for long if those were the rules. Everyone had an incentive to do the spending. No one had any incentive to do the bailouts.

EU response

''The Commission proposes to reinforce decisively the economic governance in the European Union,'' the EU said in a statement last week. Member states will have to submit their national budgets to the EU for approval.

It isn't hard to see the implications of that.

''The sovereign-debt crisis could be acting as a catalyst for an ever closer union of European countries,'' Morgan Stanley said in a May 11 note to investors. ''The decisions taken this weekend first by European leaders and then by finance ministers mark a big leap towards a fiscal union in the euro area.''

A fiscal union - in which budgets and taxes are decided centrally - would fix the problem. Member states wouldn't be able to run up unaffordable deficits. When they ran into trouble, money could be diverted from the more successful states to the ones that needed help. That's how it works within countries. It is how the euro should work, too. But here's why it probably won't.

Three reasons

First, the surrender of sovereignty is too great. Countries signed up to a single currency. They didn't sign up for a single government. Once you lose control of fiscal policy, you stop being a nation, and you become a district. It is hard to believe that will ever survive referenda or national elections. It is hard enough to persuade taxpayers to subsidize regions in the same country. Persuading electorates to send their taxes to a central authority, without having any control over where it is spent, will prove impossible.

''The budget law is a matter of national parliaments,'' Guido Westerwelle, Germany's foreign minister, said last week. ''The European Commission doesn't determine the budget. That is the job of the German Bundestag, the national parliament.''

Second, the timing is wrong. For the next five years, the only thing governments will be serving up is pain. Deficits are out of control. Spending has to be cut. Creating any kind of fiscal union was going to be tough enough even in the boom years, when you could hand out lots of cash to build new schools and roads. It will be much tougher when spending is being cut. The EU will take control of national budgets at precisely the moment they get slashed. Does that sound popular? Not really.

Third, there still isn't an enforcement mechanism. The latest proposal is that all the national budgets get submitted to Brussels in advance. The EU will approve them, or it won't.

So what happens if a budget is rejected, and local politicians tell the EU to go take a hike? Euro police aren't about to storm member parliaments and cart politicians away in handcuffs. So far, all that has been proposed is a rewrite of the stability pact, but with some more forms to fill in, and a bit of snarling if you break the rules. It didn't work last time, so why should it work now?

The EU has come up with the only realistic solution to the crisis presented by Greece's mountain of debt. But it's still not going to work. And once that becomes clear, there will be only one option left: let the euro die.

(Matthew Lynn is a Bloomberg News columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.)

Bloomberg News