Professor Shiller argues that institutional investors are fundamentally important to our economy and our society. Following his thoughts about societal changes in a modern and capitalist world, he turns his attention to the fiduciary duties of investment managers. He emphasizes the "prudent person rule," and critically reflects on the limitations that these rules impose on investment managers. Elaborating on different forms of institutional money management, he covers mutual funds, contrasting the legislative environments in the U.S. and Europe, and trusts. In the treatment of the next form, pension funds, he starts out with the history of pension funds in the late 19th and the first half of the 20th century, and subsequently presents the legislative framework for pension funds before he outlines the differences of defined benefit and defined contribution plans. Professor Shiller finishes the list of forms of institutional money management with endowments, focusing on investment mistakes in endowment management, as well as family offices and family foundations. 00:00 - Chapter 1. Assets and Liabilities of U.S. Households and Nonprofit Organizations 11:30 - Chapter 2. Human Capital and Modern Societal Changes 17:04 - Chapter 3. The Fiduciary Duty of Investment Managers 28:23 - Chapter 4. Financial Advisors, Financial Planners, and Mortgage Brokers 33:53 - Chapter 5. Comparison of Mutual Funds between the U.S. and Europe 37:58 - Chapter 6. Trusts - Providing the Opportunity to Care for Your Children 43:14 - Chapter 7. Pension Funds and Defined Contribution Plans 58:23 - Chapter 8. History of Endowment Investing 01:02:34 - Chapter 9. Family Offices and Family Foundations Complete course materials are available at the Yale Online website: online.yale.edu This course was recorded in Spring 2011.
=====
This transcript is from a Yale University lecture by Professor Robert Shiller on the role of institutional investors, financial advisors, and the evolution of financial structures in modern society. Here is a summary of the key points discussed:
1. The Scale of Household vs. Institutional Wealth
Total U.S. Household & Nonprofit Assets: ~$70 trillion (as of late 2010), including real estate, pensions, deposits, and equities.
Liabilities: ~$14 trillion (primarily mortgages), resulting in a net worth of ~$56.8 trillion.
Institutional Shift: A significant portion of assets (pension funds, mutual funds, life insurance reserves) is now managed by institutional investors. This marks a shift from 100 years ago when families managed virtually all wealth directly.
2. Human Capital and Societal Change
Human Capital: The present value of national income (~$13 trillion/year) is estimated at $260 trillion, dwarfing tangible assets and highlighting the continued importance of family and individual earning power.
Modernization: Society is moving away from family-based support (e.g., caring for elderly parents) toward institutional solutions (pension funds, assisted living, health plans) to provide more choice and professional risk management.
3. Fiduciary Duty and Regulation
Prudent Person Rule: Institutional investors are legally required to manage money with the care of a "prudent person." This rule historically encouraged conservative investing (e.g., government bonds) but was interpreted more aggressively over time (e.g., Yale’s David Swensen investing in startups), contributing to financial bubbles.
Dodd-Frank Act (2010): In response to the financial crisis, the act shifted focus from the vague "prudent person" standard to explicit "prudential standards" enforced by government regulators (FSOC), particularly regarding leverage.
4. Financial Advisors and Planners
Regulation: Financial advisors are regulated by the SEC and must be approved by FINRA. However, "financial planners" face looser regulations, leading to concerns about bad advice (e.g., excessive leverage before the 2008 crisis).
Mortgage Brokers: Until recently, they required no licensing, allowing bad actors to operate.
5. Key Investment Vehicles
Mutual Funds: Democratized investing by offering transparent, equitable returns. U.S. funds differ from European UCITS primarily in tax treatment.
Trusts: Legal arrangements allowing money to be managed for specific individuals (e.g., handicapped children or spendthrift heirs). They ensure funds are protected from mismanagement or creditors.
6. Pension Funds Evolution
History: The first U.S. pension plan was established by American Express in 1875. Early plans were often underfunded, leading to collapses (e.g., Studebaker in 1963).
ERISA (1974): Created the Pension Benefits Guarantee Corporation (PBGC) to insure and regulate pension funds.
Shift to Defined Contribution: Due to the difficulty of guaranteeing returns (defined benefit), plans shifted to defined contribution (e.g., 401(k)s), transferring investment risk and responsibility to employees.
7. Endowments
Professional Management: Endowments (like Yale’s) support institutional missions (e.g., funding graduate students). Poor historical management (e.g., Yale investing everything in a single bank in 1825) highlights the need for diversification, a principle championed by modern managers like David Swensen.
8. Family Offices and Foundations
Family Offices: Private wealth management firms for ultra-wealthy families (typically $100M+), handling investments and estate planning.
Family Foundations: Charitable organizations (36,000 in the U.S. as of 2006) set up by wealthy families for tax benefits and philanthropy. They allow families to manage wealth for social good, outliving the original donors.
Philanthropy vs. Consumption: The lecture contrasts extravagant spending (e.g., Paul Allen’s yacht) with significant charitable giving (e.g., Paul Allen donating over $1 billion), suggesting that institutional structures enable both wealth accumulation and social contribution.
Conclusion
Professor Shiller emphasizes that while the family remains central, the world is increasingly managed by professional institutional investors. Despite growing pains and regulatory challenges, this trend toward professionalization and institutionalization is shaping the governance of global wealth and addressing fundamental human needs like retirement security and philanthropy.
No comments:
Post a Comment