Wednesday 11 April 2012

Valuing a company using adjusted P/E

Average long-term P/E = 15

Company average long term P/E = 13 ( =$530m / $41m)

Market cap = $530 m
ttm Earnings = $41 m
$161 m in cash (no debt) or $4.75 per share

Cash-adjusted P/E is 9.[ = ($530m - $161m) / $41m]

Earnings yield ( 1/PE) of 11% is too cheap.

If company has a lot of debt, you wouldn't bother about the cash-adjusted P/E.

Simple DCF

Valuation

At the end of the day, every company is worth whatever the current value of all its future cash flows are discounted backward to today's terms.


It is a hint, not an answer.  Based on a lot of assumptions, using conservative figures.

1st 10 years Cash flow. using OWNERS EARNINGS (FCF).
Cash flow beyond the 10th year (Terminal value):  Assumes growth at 3% per year.
Add all the above discounted cashflows to get the present value..

Only the FCFs are hard data, all others are assumptions.

Time 14.13
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zA8udp8uRnw&feature=relmfu

Key Points about Risks

Risk unequivocally exist in investing in any stock  ...

... but important to distinguish between volatility in stock price and business risk ...

... and my point is that none are large or imminent enough to explain why shares are so cheap.

Worthy of a look?


Not sexy, high growth or hot stock.

Warning:  May not be in your "circle of competence."

Look at things that are temporary out of favour.

You wish to buy when the prices are falling or close to the bottom.

You should have a tough time trying to buy something that is NOT near its 52 weeks low.



Worthy of a look?


Moat?Thumbs Up

Cheap?Thumbs Up

Margin of safety?Thumbs Up

Inside my circle!Thumbs Up


Outcome:

No list
Watch list
Yes list

A large percentage of companies are too difficult to analyse, they are outside your circle of competence.  

Concentrated Ideas

"Wide diversification is only required when investors do not understand what they are doing."

-  Warren Buffett


Note:  Focus concentration of about 10% in each stock.  Anything stock that is less than 5% may not be worth your effort.

Margin of Safety

"Confronted with a like challenge to distill the secret of sound investment into three words, we venture the motto, MARGIN OF SAFETY."

- Ben Graham

Mr. Market

Stock prices are quotes from an emotionally unstable business partner.

Use or ignore them as you see fit.

Valuing a Business

"The critical investment factor is determining the intrinsic value of a business and paying a fair or bargain price."

- Warren Buffett

Moats

Low cost producer
Switching costs
Economies of scale
Intangibles
Regulatory
IP (Intellectual Property)
Network effects


Note:  Most companies do not have moat.  They can only survive and compete through being more efficient.

Circle of Competence

If we have a strength, it is in recognizing when we are operating well within our circle of competence and when we are approaching the perimeter.

Warren Buffett

Value Investing












Cale Smith, portfolio manager at Islamorada Investment Management, gives a talk on value investing at the New Jersey Institute of Technology in 2010.http://www.islainvest.com for more.

Introduction to Value Investing

How to Pick Your Investment Style

The Best of Value Investing

How to Value a Company in 3 Easy Steps

Valuing Stocks and Bonds




Financial Statements Explained

Consolidated Financial Statements

How to Choose Dividend Stocks - Morningstar