- On the New York Stock Exchange, the NYSE American, and Nasdaq, 90% of the common stocks trade above their 10-day moving averages.
- Stocks advancing on the NYSE outpace those declining by nearly a 2-to-1 margin for at least 10 days.
- More than 55% of the stocks on the NYSE set new highs over a 20-day period.
Keep INVESTING Simple and Safe (KISS) ****Investment Philosophy, Strategy and various Valuation Methods**** The same forces that bring risk into investing in the stock market also make possible the large gains many investors enjoy. It’s true that the fluctuations in the market make for losses as well as gains but if you have a proven strategy and stick with it over the long term you will be a winner!****Warren Buffett: Rule No. 1 - Never lose money. Rule No. 2 - Never forget Rule No. 1.
Friday, 6 January 2023
Bear-Market Rally or New Bull?
The three bears scenario: how the bear market plays out if a recession occurs in 2022, 2023 or not at all.
In its “three bears” scenario, NDR lays out possibilities for how the bear market plays out if a recession occurs this year, next year, or not at all.
1. If a recession occurs sometime in the second half of 2022, the stock market could drop another 10% or more. Bear markets that coincide with recessions tend to decline nearly 35% on average and last for 15.3 months. If this were to be the case, the sooner it would start, the sooner it would be over given that a bear market bottoms four months before a recession, setting the stage for a “shorter than average” recessionary bear market.
2. If a recession occurs in 2023 that would make the current bear market twice as long as average, and likely lead to numerous bear-market rallies that eventually fail as they have in past instances. Clissold cites 1973, 1978, and 2000 as past bear markets that saw numerous rallies between their start and finish with a maximum gain of 15.9%, 14.3%, and 15.5%, respectively.
3. The last and best scenario is if there is no recession at all. Stocks decline on average by 25% in a non-recessionary bear market over 9.1 months. In the past 50 years, the average decline has been 18% over 6.8 months.
If the Fed can achieve the delicate balance of taming inflation by slowing the economy without tipping the country into a recession, Clissold says, “the cyclical bear is likely close to being over.”
NDR = Ned Davis Research, an independent provider of global investment research based in Nokomis, Florida
How Do You Tell a Bear-Market Rally in Stocks From a New Bull Run? | Morningstar
Bed Bath & Beyond shares plummet after company warns of potential bankruptcy
Bed Bath & Beyond shares plummet after company warns of potential bankruptcy
- Bed Bath & Beyond warned Thursday it’s running out of cash and is considering bankruptcy.
- The embattled home goods retailer is having trouble getting enough merchandise to fill its shelves and is drawing fewer customers to its stores and website.
- It anticipates a net loss of about $385.8 million for the third quarter, a nearly 40% jump in losses year over year.
Thursday, 5 January 2023
UOB One Savings Account Raises Interest Rates to 7.8% - Should You Save Or Invest?
Enya Rodrigues
12 December 2022·
Earlier this week, UOB announced that they are raising the interest rate of their One Savings Account to up to 7.8% p.a interest. UOB is not alone in doing so. Across the board, we see banks in Singapore fighting to remain competitive by offering increasingly attractive interest rates to encourage people to deposit their money with them.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, many countries were cutting their federal interest rates in an effort to increase lending and spending in order to stimulate the economy. This led to record low levels of interest rates on savings accounts. Many individuals opted to expose themselves to some level of risk and invest their savings rather than leave them idle in low-interest savings accounts.
However, with the current upsized interest rates on savings accounts, is it still worthwhile to invest your money into various investment vehicles, such as fixed deposits, treasury bills or even ETFs, or are you better off saving your money in a high-interest savings account?
If You Have A Small Amount Of Savings
One major caveat to the current high-interest rate promotions banks are running on their savings accounts is that you need a large amount of money in your savings account to be able to reap the full advertised interest rate.
For example, with the UOB One savings account, you are only able to enjoy the full 7.8% interest on your savings if you have an account monthly average balance of over S$75,000.
If you have less than S$30,000 in your savings account, you will only enjoy an interest rate of 3.85% p.a. This is almost half of the advertised high-interest rate of 7.8% p.a.
This is in contrast to the six-month tenor for Singapore Treasury Bills, released on 8 December 2022, which has an interest rate of 4.30%. The minimum bid amount for a Treasury Bill is S$1,000. Hence, with a smaller amount of money, you can get a higher rate of return if you invest rather than place your money in a high-interest savings account.
Furthermore, if you do not have a large amount of capital right now but are able to budget a small amount of your monthly income towards investing, taking a dollar-cost averaging approach might also be more lucrative for you in the long run.
The S&P 500, an index that tracks the 500 largest companies in the United States, has averaged an annual rate of return of 11.88% from 1957 to 2021. Choosing to dollar-cost average into an ETF every month might be a better allocation of your money. Granted, this incurs more risk than a savings account as you are exposing yourself to market volatility. However, the risk-to-reward ratio might be easier to stomach when working with a smaller budget.
If You Have A Large Amount Of Savings
Conversely, if you have a large amount of capital, choosing to deposit it into a high-interest savings account like UOB One might be a good option. With Singapore’s inflation rate in 2022 sitting at around 6%, an interest rate of 7.8% is not only matching but slightly beating inflation.
There are currently very low hurdles to achieve the 7.8% p.a. interest rate on deposit accounts with more than S$75,000. All that is required is for you to credit your monthly salary of at least S$1,600 into your UOB One account and spend at least S$500 on any UOB credit or debit card. For the average working adult, it should not be too difficult to meet this requirement.
Savings accounts are seen as an extremely low-risk asset. The Singapore Deposit Insurance Corporation (SDIC) insures all member banks and financial companies for up to S$75,000. This means that in the very unlikely event that a bank goes bankrupt, all of your deposits, up to S$75,000, will be guaranteed and returned to you. Hence, there is very little risk of you losing your initial capital, unlike when you are invested in the stock market.
Furthermore, a savings account provides the most liquidity. There is no lock-up period like with a fixed deposit or Singapore treasury bill. Savings accounts are also not subject to market fluctuations the way ETFs are. If you need to dip into this pot of savings for emergencies or investing opportunities along the way, you can do so without facing any penalties or losses.
This prevents one from jumping into an investment that they do not have a full understanding of just because they do not want to let their idle cash get eroded by inflation. With a high-interest savings account, you are able to buy yourself time to wait on the sidelines for the perfect investment opportunity to arise.
Conclusion
Whether you choose to take advantage of the high-interest savings accounts now or to continue investing depends on both your personal financial situation and risk appetite.
While choosing to invest may not be as lucrative a decision if you have a smaller amount of savings, the peace of mind you get from knowing that your money is currently accruing interest in a rather risk-free vehicle could be good enough, even if you do not enjoy the full 7.8% p.a. interest rate.
For more information on different options available to you on the market right now, check out our round-up of the best savings accounts out there.
Reference:
https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/uob-one-savings-account-raises-022013039.html
Read Also: Best Savings Accounts in Singapore 2022
https://www.valuechampion.sg/bank-accounts/best-savings-accounts-singapore
Wednesday, 4 January 2023
"We Want to Be More Cautious." Goldman Sachs CEO on 2023's Global Financial Outlook
Monday, 2 January 2023
Glossary (7)
Glossary
Tax-loss selling—selling just prior to year-end to realize losses for tax purposes
Technical analysis—analysis of past security-price fluctuations using charts
Tender offer—a cash bid to buy some or all of the securities of a target company
Thrift conversion—the conversion of a mutual thrift institution to stock ownership
Top-down investing—strategy involving making a macroeconomic forecast and then applying it to choose individual investments
Torpedo stocks—stocks for which investors have high expectations and which are therefore vulnerable to substantial price declines
Trader—a person whose job it is to buy and sell securities, earning a spread or commission for bringing buyers and sellers together
Trading flat—available for sale or purchase without payment for accrued interest
Treasury bills (T-bills)—noninterest-bearing obligations of the U.S. government, issued on a discount basis with original maturities ranging from three months to one year; the interest income from Treasury bills is the difference between the purchase price and par
Treasury bonds (T-bonds) —U.S. government obligations with original maturities of ten years or more; interest is paid semiannually
Treasury notes (T-notes) —U.S. government obligations with original maturities ranging from one to ten years; interest is paid semiannually
Value - the worth, calculated through fundamental analysis, of an asset, business, or security
Value investing—a risk-averse investment approach designed to buy securities at a discount from underlying value
Value investment—undervalued security; a bargain
Volume—the number of shares traded
Window dressing—the practice of making a portfolio look good for quarterly reporting purposes
Working capital—current assets minus current liabilities
Writing call options—selling call options on securities owned
Yield —return calculated over a specific period
Zero-coupon bond—a bond that accrues interest until maturity rather than paying it in cash
Glossary (6)
Glossary
Puttable bond—bond with embedded put features allowing holders to sell the bonds back to the issuer at a specified price and time (see callable bond)
Recapitalization—financial restructuring of a company whereby the company borrows against its assets and distributes the proceeds to shareholders
Relative-performance orientation—the tendency to evaluate investment results by comparing one’s investment performance with that of the market as a whole
Return—potential gain
Rights offering—a financing technique whereby a company issues to its shareholders the preemptive right to purchase new stock (or bonds) in the company or occasionally in a subsidiary company
Risk—amount and probability of potential loss
Risk arbitrage—a specialized area involving investment in far-from-risk-free takeovers as well as spinoffs, liquidations, and other extraordinary corporate transactions
Secured debt—debt backed by a security interest in specific assets
Security—a marketable piece of paper representing the fractional ownership of a business or loan to a business or government entity
Self-tender—an offer by a company to repurchase its own securities
Senior-debt security—security with the highest priority in the hierarchy of a company’s capital structure
Sensitivity analysis—a method of ascertaining the sensitivity of business value to small changes in the assumptions made by investors
Share buybacks—corporate stock repurchases
Shareholder’s (owner’s) equity—the residual after liabilities are subtracted from assets
Short-selling—the sale of a borrowed security (see going long)
Short-term relative-performance derby—manifestation of the tendency by institutional investors to measure investment results, not against an absolute standard, but against broad stock market indices resulting in an often speculative orientation
Sinking fund—obligation of a company to periodically retire part of a bond issue prior to maturity
Speculation—an asset having no underlying economics and throwing off no cash flow to the benefit of its owner (see investment)
Spinoff—the distribution of the shares of a subsidiary company to the shareholders of the parent company
Stock—a marketable piece of paper representing the fractional ownership of an underlying business
Stock index Futures—contracts for the future delivery of a market basket of stocks
Stock market proxy—estimate of the price at which a company, or its subsidiaries considered separately, would trade in the stock market
Subordinated-debt security - security with a secondary priority in the hierarchy of a company’s capital structure
Tactical-asset allocation—computer program designed to indicate whether stocks or bonds are a better buy
Takeover multiple— multiple of earnings, cash flow, or revenues paid to acquire a company
Tangible asset—an asset physically in existence
Glossary (5)
Glossary
Net operating-loss carryforward (NOL)—the carryforward of past losses for tax purposes, enabling a company to shield future income from taxation
Net present value (NPV)—calculation of the value of an investment by discounting future estimates of cash flow back to the present
Non-cash-pay securities—securities permitted to pay interest or dividends in kind or at a later date rather than in cash as due (see cash-pay securities, pay-in-kind, and zero-coupon bond)
Nonrecourse—the lender looks only to the borrowing entity for payment
Open end mutual fund—mutual fund offering to issue or redeem shares at a price equal to underlying net asset value
Opportunity cost—the loss represented by forgone opportunities
Option—the right to buy (call) or sell (put) specified items at specified prices by specified dates
Over-the-counter (OTC)—the market for stocks not listed on a securities exchange (e.g., New York, American, Philadelphia, Boston, Pacific, Toronto)
Par—the face amount of a bond; the contractual amount of the bondholder’s claim
Pay-in-kind (PIK)—a security paying interest or dividends in kind rather than in cash
Plan of reorganization—the terms under which a company expects to emerge from Chapter 11 bankruptcy
Portfolio cash flow—the cash flowing into a portfolio net of outflows
Portfolio insurance—a strategy involving the periodic sale of stock-index futures designed to eliminate downside risk in a portfolio at a minor up-front cost
Post petition interest—interest accruing from the date of a bankruptcy filing forward
Preferred stock—an equity security senior in priority to common stock with a specified entitlement to dividend payments
Prepackaged bankruptcy—a technique whereby each class of creditors in a bankruptcy agree on a plan of reorganization prior to the bankruptcy filing
Prepetition interest—interest accruing from the most recent coupon payment up to the date of a bankruptcy filing
Price/earnings (P/E) ratio—market price of a stock divided by the annualized earnings per share
Price-to-book-value ratio—market price of a stock divided by book value per share
Principal— the face amount or par value of a debt security
Principal-only mortgage security (PO)—principal payments stripped from a pool of mortgages which, in response to changes in interest rates, fluctuate in value in the same direction as conventional mortgages but with greater volatility
Private-market value—the price that a sophisticated businessperson would be likely to pay for a business based on the valuation multiples paid on similar transactions
Pro forma financial information —earnings and book value adjusted to reflect a recent or proposed merger, recapitalization, tender offer, or other extraordinary transaction
Proxy contest—a fight for corporate control through the solicitation of proxies or the election of directors
Prudent-man standard—the obligation under ERISA to restrict one’s investments to those a “prudent” (conservative) person would make (see Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA)
Put option—a contract enabling the purchaser to sell a security at a fixed price on a particular date
Glossary (4)
Glossary
Inside information—information unavailable to the public, upon which it is illegal to base transactions
Institutional investors —money managers, pension fund managers, and managers of mutual funds
Intangible asset—an asset without physical presence; examples include intellectual property rights (patents) or going-concern value (goodwill)
Interest—payment for the use of borrowed money
Interest-coverage ratio—the ratio of pretax earnings to interest expense
Interest-only mortgage security (IO)—interest payments stripped from a pool of mortgages which, for a given change in interest rates, fluctuates in value inversely to conventional mortgages (see principal-only mortgage security)
Interest rate reset—a promise made by an issuer to adjust the coupon on a bond at a specified future date in order to cause it to trade at a predetermined price
Internal rate of return (IRR)—calculation of the rate of return of an investment that assumes reinvestment of cash flows at the same rate of return the investment itself offers
Investment—an asset purchased to provide a return; investments, in contrast to speculations, eventually generate cash flow for the benefit of the owners (see speculation)
Investment banking—profession involving raising capital for companies as well as underwriting and trading securities, arranging for the purchase and sale of entire companies, providing financial advice, and opining on the fairness of specific transactions
Investment grade—fixed income security rated BBB or higher
Junk bond - fixed-income security rated below investment grade
Leveraged buyout (LBO)—acquisition of a business by an investor group relying heavily on debt financing
Liability—a debt or other obligation to pay
Liquidating distribution—cash or securities distributed to shareholders by a company in the process of liquidation
Liquidating trust—an entity established to complete a corporate liquidation
Liquidation value—the expected proceeds if the assets of a company were sold off, but not as part of an ongoing enterprise
Liquidity—having ample cash on hand
Liquid security—a security that trades frequently and within a narrow spread between the bid and asked prices
Making a market—acting as a securities dealer by simultaneously bidding for and offering a security
Margin of safety—investing at considerable discounts from underlying value, an individual provides himself or herself room for imprecision, bad luck, or analytical error (i.e., a “margin of safety”) while avoiding sizable losses
Market price—the price of the most recent transaction in a company’s publicly traded stock or bonds
Maturity—the date on which the face value of a debt security is due and payable
Merchant banking—an activity whereby Wall Street firms commit their own capital while acting as principal in investment banking transactions
Merger—a combination of two corporations into one
Mutual fund—a pooled investment portfolio managed by professional investors
Net asset value (NAV)—the per share value of a mutual fund calculated by dividing the total market value of assets by the number of shares outstanding
Net-net working capital—net working capital less all long-term liabilities
Glossary (3)
Glossary
Efficient— market hypothesis-speculative notion that all information about securities is disseminated and becomes fully reflected in security prices instantaneously
Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA)—legislation that requires institutional investors to act as fiduciaries for future retirees by adopting the “prudent-man standard” (see prudent-man standard)
Equity “stubs”—low priced, highly leveraged stocks, often resulting from a corporate recapitalization (see recapitalization)
Exchange offer—an offer made by a company to its security holders to exchange new, less-onerous securities for those outstanding
“Fallen angels”—bonds of companies that have deteriorated beneath investment grade in credit quality
Financial distress—the condition of a business experiencing a shortfall of cash to meet operating needs and scheduled debt-service requirements
Friendly takeover—corporate acquisition in which the buyer and seller both support the transaction enthusiastically
Fulcrum securities—the class of securities whose strict priority bankruptcy claim is most immediately affected by changes in the debtor’s value
Full position—ownership of as much of a given security as an investor is willing to hold
Fundamental analysis— analyzing securities based on the operating performance (fundamentals) of the underlying business
Ginnie Mae (GNMA)—pool of mortgages insured by the Government National Mortgage Association, a U.S. government agency
Going long —buying a security (see short-selling)
Goodwill amortization—the gradual expensing of the intangible asset known as goodwill, which comes into existence when a company is purchased for more than its tangible book value
Guaranteed investment contract (GIC)—an insurance-company-sponsored investment product that automatically reinvests interest at a contractual rate
Hedge—an investment that, by appreciating (depreciating) inversely to another, has the effect of cushioning price changes in the latter
Holding company—a corporate structure in which one company (the holding company) is the owner of another
Hold-up value— benefits accruing to participants in a class of securities who are able to extract considerable nuisance value from the holders of other classes of securities
Illiquid security—a security that trades infrequently, usually with a large spread between the bid and asked prices (see liquid security)
Income statement—accounting statement calculating a company’s profit or loss
Indexing—the practice of buying all the components of a market index, such as the Standard and Poor’s 500 index, in proportion to the weightings of that index and then passively holding them
Initial public offering (IPO)—underwriting of a stock being offered to the public for the first time
Glossary (2)
Glossary
Catalyst—an internally or externally instigated corporate event that results in security holders realizing some or all of a company’s underlying value
Chapter 11—a section of the federal bankruptcy code whereby a debtor is reorganized as a going concern rather than liquidated (see bankruptcy)
Closed-end mutual fund—mutual fund having a fixed number of outstanding shares that trade based on supply and demand at prices not necessarily equal to underlying net asset value (see open-end mutual fund)
Collateralized bond obligation (CBO)—diversified investment pools of junk bonds that issue their own securities, usually in several tranches, each of which has risk and return characteristics that differ from those of the underlying junk bonds themselves
Commercial paper—short-term loans from institutional investors to businesses
Commission—a charge for transacting in securities
Complex securities—securities with unusual cash flow characteristics
Contingent-value rights—tradable rights that are redeemable for cash if a stock fails to reach specified price levels
Convertible arbitrage—arbitrage transactions designed to take advantage of price discrepancies between convertible securities and the securities into which they are convertible
Convertible bonds—bonds that can be exchanged for common stock or other assets of a company at a specified price
Coupon—the specified interest payment on a bond expressed as a percentage
Covered-call writing—the practice of purchasing common stocks and then selling call options against them
Cram-down security—security distributed in a merger transaction, not sold by an underwriter
Credit cycle—the ebb and flow in the availability of credit
Debtor-in-possession (DIP) financing—loan to a bankrupt company operating in Chapter 11
Debt-to-equity ratio—the ratio of a company’s outstanding debt to the book value of its equity; a measure of a company’s financial leverage
Default—the status of a company that fails to make an interest or principal payment on a debt security on the required date
Default rate of junk bonds—calculated by many junk-band-market participants as the dollar volume of junk-bond defaults occurring in a particular year divided by the total volume of junk bonds outstanding
Depreciation—an accounting procedure by which long-lived assets are capitalized and then expensed over time
Discount rate—the rate of interest that would make an investor indifferent between present and future dollars
Diversification—ownership of many rather than a small number of securities; the goal of diversification is to limit the risk of company-specific events on one’s portfolio as a whole
Dividend—cash distributed by a company to its shareholders out of after-tax earnings
Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA)—a nonsensical number thought by some investors to represent the cash flow of a business
Earnings per share—a company’s after-tax earnings divided by the total number of shares outstanding
Glossary (1)
Glossary
Absolute-performance orientation—the tendency to evaluate investment results by measuring one’s investment performance against an absolute standard such as the risk-free rate of return
Annuity—a stream of cash in perpetuity
Arbitrage— the practice of investing in risk-free transactions to take advantage of pricing discrepancies between markets (see risk arbitrage)
Arbitrageur—investor in risk-arbitrage transactions
Asked price (offer)—the price at which a security is offered for sale (see bid price)
Asset—something owned by a business or individual
Average down—to buy more of a security for less than one’s earlier purchase price(s), resulting in a reduction of the average cost
Balance sheet— accounting statement of a company’s assets, liabilities, and net worth
Bankruptcy—a legal state wherein a debtor (borrower) is temporarily protected from creditors (lenders); under Chapter 11 of the federal bankruptcy code, companies may continue to operate
Bear market—an environment characterized by generally declining share prices (see bull market)
Beta—a statistical measure used by some academics and market professionals to quantify investment risk by comparing a security’s or portfolio’s historical price performance with that of the market as a whole
Bid price—the price a potential buyer is willing to pay for a security (see asked price)
Blocking position—the ownership of a sufficient percentage of a class of securities to prevent undesirable actions from occurring (a creditor owning one-third or more of a class of bankrupt debt securities is able to “block” approval of a plan of reorganization not to his or her liking)
Bond—a security representing a loan to a business or government entity
Book value—the historical accounting of shareholders’ equity; this is, in effect, the residual after liabilities are subtracted from assets
Bottom—up investing-strategy involving the identification of specific undervalued investment opportunities one at a time through fundamental analysis
Breakup value—the expected proceeds if the assets of a company were sold to the highest bidder, whether as a going concern or not (see liquidation value)
Bull market—an environment characterized by generally rising share prices (see bear market)
Callable bond—a bond that may be retired by the issuer at a specified price prior to its contractual maturity (see puttable bond)
Call option—a contract enabling the owner to purchase a security at a fixed price on a particular date (see put option)
Cash flow—the cash gain or loss experienced by a business during a particular period of operations
Cash-pay securities—securities required to make interest or dividend payments in cash (see non-cash-pay securities)
Sunday, 1 January 2023
Investment Research and Inside Information
How far is it reasonable to go in pursuit of information
The investment research process is complicated by the blurred line between publicly available and inside, or privileged, information.
Although trading based on inside information is illegal, the term has never been clearly defined.
As investors seek to analyze investments and value securities, they bump into the unresolved question of how far they may reasonably go in the pursuit of information.
- For example, can an investor presume that information provided by a corporate executive is public knowledge (assuming, of course, that suitcases of money do not change hands)?
- Similarly, is information that emanates from a stockbroker in the public domain?
- How about information from investment bankers?
- If not the latter, then why do investors risk talking to them, and why are the investment bankers willing to speak?
- How deep may they dig?
- May they hire private investigators, and may those investigators comb through a company’s garbage?
- What, if any, are the limits?
Debt market
The troubled debt market, for example, is event driven.
Takeovers, exchange offers, and open-market bond repurchases are fairly routine.
What is public knowledge, and what is not?
- If you sell bonds back to a company, which then retires them, is knowledge of that trade inside information?
- Does it matter how many bonds were sold or when the trade occurred?
- If this constitutes inside information, in what way does it restrict you?
- If you are a large bondholder and the issuer contacts you to discuss an exchange offer, in what way can that be construed as inside information?
When does inside information become sufficiently old to no longer be protected?
- When do internal financial projections become outdated?
- When do aborted merger plans cease to be secret?
There are no firm answers to these questions.
Stay within the law, err on the side of ignorance or seek advice
Investors must bend over backward to stay within the law, of course, but it would be far easier if the law were more clearly enunciated.
Since it is not, law abiding investors must err on the side of ignorance, investing with less information than those who are not so ethical.
When investors are unsure whether they have crossed the line, they would be well advised to ask their sources and perhaps their attorneys as well before making any trades.
Conclusion
Investment research is the process of reducing large piles of information to manageable ones, distilling the investment wheat from the chaff.
There is, needless to say, a lot of chaff and very little wheat.
The research process itself, like the factory of a manufacturing company, produces no profits.
The profits materialize later, often much later, when the undervaluation identified during the research process is first translated into portfolio decisions and then eventually recognized by the market.
In fact, often there is no immediate buying opportunity; today’s research may be advance preparation for tomorrow’s opportunities.
In any event, just as a superior sales force cannot succeed if the factory does not produce quality goods, an investment program will not long succeed if high-quality research is not performed on a continuing basis.
Insider Buying and Management Stock Options Can Signal Opportunity
Only one reason for insider buying
In their search for complete information on businesses, investors often overlook one very important clue. In most instances no one understands a business and its prospects better than the management.
Therefore investors should be encouraged when corporate insiders invest their own money alongside that of shareholders by purchasing stock in the open market.
It is often said on Wall Street that there are many reasons why an insider might sell a stock (need for cash to pay taxes, expenses, etc.), but there is only one reason for buying.
Investors can track insider buying and selling in any of several specialized publications, such as Vickers Stock Research.
Management stock-options provide the specific incentive to boost the company's share price
The motivation of corporate management can be a very important force in determining the outcome of an investment.
Some companies provide incentives for their managements with stock-option plans and related vehicles.
Usually these plans give management the specific incentive to do what they can to boost the company’s share price.
Be alert to the motivations of managements at the companies
While management does not control a company’s stock price, it can greatly influence the gap between share price and underlying value and over time can have a significant influence on value itself.
If the management of a company were compensated based on revenues, total assets, or even net income, it might ignore share price while focusing on those indicators of corporate performance.
If, however, management were provided incentives to maximize share price, it would focus its attention differently.
- For example, the management of a company whose stock sold at $25 with an underlying value of $50 could almost certainly boost the market price by announcing a spinoff, recapitalization, or asset sale, with the result of narrowing the gap between share price and underlying value.
- The repurchase of shares on the open market at $25 would likely give a boost to the share price as well as causing the underlying value of remaining shares to increase above $50.
Obviously investors need to be alert to the motivations of managements at the companies in which they invest.
How Much Research and Analysis Are Sufficient?
Two shortcomings on trying to obtain perfect knowledge
Some investors insist on trying to obtain perfect knowledge about their impending investments, researching companies until they think they know everything there is to know about them.
They study the industry and the competition, contact former employees, industry consultants, and analysts, and become personally acquainted with top management.
They analyze financial statements for the past decade and stock price trends for even longer.
This diligence is admirable, but it has two shortcomings.
- First, no matter how much research is performed, some information always remains elusive; investors have to learn to live with less than complete information.
- Second, even if an investor could know all the facts about an investment, he or she would not necessarily profit.
80/20 rule
This is not to say that fundamental analysis is not useful. It certainly is.
But information generally follows the well-known 80/20 rule: the first 80 percent of the available information is gathered in the first 20 percent of the time spent.
The value of in-depth fundamental analysis is subject to diminishing marginal returns.
Information is not always easy to obtain.
Some companies actually impede its flow. Understandably, proprietary information must be kept confidential.
The requirement that all investors be kept on an equal footing is another reason for the limited dissemination of information; information limited to a privileged few might be construed as inside information.
Restrictions on the dissemination of information can complicate investors’ quest for knowledge nevertheless.
Business information is highly perishable.
Moreover, business information is highly perishable.
Economic conditions change, industries are transformed, and business results are volatile.
The effort to acquire current, let alone complete information is never-ending.
Meanwhile, other market participants are also gathering and updating information, thereby diminishing any investor’s informational advantage.
David Dreman recounts “the story of an analyst so knowledgeable about Clorox that ‘he could recite bleach shares by brand in every small town in the Southwest and tell you the production levels of Clorox’s line number 2, plant number 3. But somehow, when the company began to develop massive problems, he missed the signs....’ The stock fell from a high of 53 to 11.”
Wall Street analysts' recommendations may be less than stellar
Although many Wall Street analysts have excellent insight into industries and individual companies, the results of investors who follow their recommendations may be less than stellar. In part this is due to the pressure placed on these analysts
- to recommend frequently rather than wisely, but
- it also exemplifies the difficulty of translating information into profits.
Industry analysts are not well positioned to evaluate the stocks they follow in the context of competing investment alternatives.
- Merrill Lynch’s pharmaceutical analyst may know everything there is to know about Merck and Pfizer, but he or she knows virtually nothing about General Motors, Treasury bond yields, and Jones & Laughlin Steel first-mortgage bonds.
Investors frequently benefit from uncertainty and making decision with less than perfect knowledge
Most investors strive fruitlessly for certainty and precision, avoiding situations in which information is difficult to obtain.
Yet high uncertainty is frequently accompanied by low prices. By the time the uncertainty is resolved, prices are likely to have risen.
Investors frequently benefit from making investment decisions with less than perfect knowledge and are well rewarded for bearing the risk of uncertainty.
The time other investors spend delving into the last unanswered detail may cost them the chance to buy in at prices so low that they offer a margin of safety despite the incomplete information.
Value Investing and Contrarian Thinking
Value investing by its very nature is contrarian.
Out-of-favor securities may be undervalued; popular securities almost never are.
What the herd is buying is, by definition, in favor.
Securities in favor have already been bid up in price on the basis of optimistic expectations and are unlikely to represent good value that has been overlooked.
Where may value exist?
If value is not likely to exist in what the herd is buying, where may it exist?
In what they are
- selling,
- unaware of, or
- ignoring.
When the herd is selling a security, the market price may fall well beyond reason.
Ignored, obscure, or newly created securities may similarly be or become undervalued.
Contrarians are almost always initially wrong
Investors may find it difficult to act as contrarians for they can never be certain whether or when they will be proven correct.
Since they are acting against the crowd, contrarians are almost always initially wrong and likely for a time to suffer paper losses.
By contrast, members of the herd are nearly always right for a period.
Not only are contrarians initially wrong, they may be wrong more often and for longer periods than others because market trends can continue long past any limits warranted by underlying value.
When contrary opinion can be put to use.
Holding a contrary opinion is not always useful to investors, however.
1. When widely held opinions have no influence on the issue at hand, nothing is gained by swimming against the tide.
- It is always the consensus that the sun will rise tomorrow, but this view does not influence the outcome.
2. By contrast, when majority opinion does affect the outcome or the odds, contrary opinion can be put to use.
- When the herd rushes into home health-care stocks, bidding up prices and thereby lowering available returns, the majority has altered the risk/ reward ratio, allowing contrarians to bet against the crowd with the odds skewed in their favor.
- When investors in 1983 either ignored or panned the stock of Nabisco, causing it to trade at a discount to other food companies, the risk/reward ratio became more favorable, creating a buying opportunity for contrarians.
Market Inefficiencies and Institutional Constraints cause stocks to sell at depressed prices
Ask: Why the bargain has become available?
The research task does not end with the discovery of an apparent bargain. It is incumbent on investors to try to find out why the bargain has become available.
- If in 1990 you were looking for an ordinary, four-bedroom colonial home on a quarter acre in the Boston suburbs, you should have been prepared to pay at least $300,000.
- If you learned of one available for $150,000, your first reaction would not have been, “What a great bargain!” but, “What’s wrong with it?”
A bargain should be inspected and re-inspected for possible flaws.
The same healthy skepticism applies to the stock market. A bargain should be inspected and re-inspected for possible flaws.
- Irrational or indifferent selling alone may have made it cheap, but there may be more fundamental reasons for the depressed price.
- Perhaps there are contingent liabilities or pending litigation that you are unaware of.
- Maybe a competitor is preparing to introduce a superior product.
When reason for undervaluation can be clearly identified, the outcome is more predictable
When the reason for the undervaluation can be clearly identified, it becomes an even better investment because the outcome is more predictable.
- By way of example, the legal constraint that prevents some institutional investors from purchasing low-priced spinoffs is one possible explanation for undervaluation. Such reasons give investors some comfort that the price is not depressed for an undisclosed fundamental business reason.
- Other institutional constraints can also create opportunities for value investors. For example, many institutional investors become major sellers of securities involved in risk-arbitrage transactions on the grounds that their mission is to invest in ongoing businesses, not speculate on takeovers. The resultant selling pressure can depress prices, increasing the returns available to arbitrage investors.
- Institutional investors are commonly unwilling to buy or hold low-priced securities. Since any company can exercise a degree of control over its share price through splitting or reverse splitting its outstanding shares, the financial rationale for this constraint is hard to understand. Why would a company’s shares be a good buy at $15 a share but not at $3 after a five for-one stock split or vice versa?
Market inefficiencies cause stocks to sell at depressed levels
1. Obscurity and a very thin market can cause stocks to sell at depressed levels.
Many attractive investment opportunities result from market inefficiencies, that is, areas of the security markets in which information is not fully disseminated or in which supply and demand are temporarily out of balance.
Almost no one on Wall Street, for example, follows, let alone recommends, small companies whose shares are closely held and infrequently traded; there are at most a handful of market makers in such stocks. Depending on the number of shareholders, such companies may not even be required by the SEC to file quarterly or annual reports.
2. Year-end tax selling also creates market inefficiencies.
- The Internal Revenue Code makes it attractive for investors to realize capital losses before the end of each year.
- Selling driven by the calendar rather than by investment fundamentals frequently causes stocks that declined significantly during the year to decline still further.
- This generates opportunities for value investors.
Knowing where to look for opportunities to invest
Investment Research: The Challenge of Finding Attractive Investments
Investors are in the business of processing information
While knowing how to value businesses is essential for investment success, the first and perhaps most important step in the investment process is knowing where to look for opportunities.
Investors are in the business of processing information, but while studying the current financial statements of the thousands of publicly held companies, the monthly, weekly, and even daily research reports of hundreds of Wall Street analysts, and the market behavior of scores of stocks and bonds, they will spend virtually all their time reviewing fairly priced securities that are of no special interest.
Good investment ideas are rare
Good investment ideas are rare and valuable things, which must be ferreted out assiduously. They do not fly in over the transom or materialize out of thin air. Investors cannot assume that good ideas will come effortlessly
- from scanning the recommendations of Wall Street analysts, no matter how highly regarded, or
- from punching up computers, no matter how cleverly programmed,
Upon occasion attractive opportunities are so numerous that the only limiting factor is the availability of funds to invest; typically the number of attractive opportunities is much more limited.
By identifying where the most attractive opportunities are likely to arise before starting one’s quest for the exciting handful of specific investments, investors can spare themselves an often fruitless survey of the humdrum majority of available investments.
Three categories of specialized investment niches
Value investing encompasses a number of specialized investment niches that can be divided into three categories:
- securities selling at a discount to breakup or liquidation value,
- rate-of-return situations, and
- asset-conversion opportunities.
Where to look for opportunities
Where to look for opportunities varies from one of these categories to the next.
1. Computer-screening techniques, for example, can be helpful in identifying stocks of the first category: those selling at a discount from liquidation value. Because databases can be out of date or inaccurate, however, it is essential that investors verify that the computer output is correct.
2. Risk arbitrage and complex securities comprise a second category of attractive value investments with known exit prices and approximate time frames, which, taken together, enable investors to calculate expected rates of return at the time the investments are made.
- Mergers, tender offers, and other risk arbitrage transactions are widely reported in the daily financial press – the Wall Street Journal and the business section of the New York Times – as well as in specialized newsletters and periodicals.
- Locating information on complex securities is more difficult, but as they often come into existence as byproducts of risk arbitrage transactions, investors who follow the latter may become aware of the former.
3. Financially distressed and bankrupt securities, corporate recapitalizations, and exchange offers all fall into the category of asset conversions, in which investors’ existing holdings are exchanged for one or more new securities.
- Distressed and bankrupt businesses are often identified in the financial press; specialized publications and research services also provide information on such companies and their securities.
- Fundamental information on troubled companies can be gleaned from published financial statements and in the case of bankruptcies, from court documents.
- Price quotations may only be available from dealers since many of these securities are not listed on any exchange.
- Corporate recapitalizations and exchange offers can usually be identified from a close reading of the daily financial press. Publicly available filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) provide extensive detail on these extraordinary corporate transactions.
4. Many undervalued securities do not fall into any of these specialized categories and are best identified through old fashioned hard work, yet there are widely available means of improving the likelihood of finding mispriced securities.
- Looking at stocks on the Wall Street Journal’s leading percentage-decline and new-low lists, for example, occasionally turns up an out-of-favor investment idea.
- Similarly, when a company eliminates its dividend, its shares often fall to unduly depressed levels.
- Of course, all companies of requisite size produce annual and quarterly reports, which they will send upon request. Filings of a company’s annual and quarterly financial statements on Forms 10K and 10Q, respectively, are available from the SEC and often from the reporting company as well.
Niche opportunities sometimes emerges
Sometimes an attractive investment niche emerges in which numerous opportunities develop over time. One such area has been the large number of thrift institutions that have converted from mutual to stock ownership.
- Investors should consider analyzing all companies within such a category in order to identify those that are undervalued.
- Specialized newsletters and industry periodicals can be excellent sources of information on such niche opportunities.