Sunday, 22 November 2026

Chapter 3: How to Invest for the Long Term and Should I Use a Financial Advisor? Chapter 4: The Dangers of Thesis Creep Chapter 5: How Do I Short Stocks

 





Chapter 3: How to Invest for the Long Term and Should I Use a Financial Advisor? — Detailed Main Points

  1. It is very difficult to beat the averages

    • Eisman says it is “very difficult to beat the averages for anyone.”

    • Most professional investors do not beat the averages over long periods of time.

    • Therefore, for individual investors, he recommends buying the indices.

  2. Which indices to buy

    • For investors with lower risk tolerance: buy the S&P 500 index; symbol SPY.

    • For investors with more risk tolerance: buy some combination of the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq, whose symbol is QQQ (“the triple Q’s”).

  3. Do not market-time

    • He would not market-time.

    • Take the emotion out of it.

    • As you save money, take a portion of those savings—whatever you can afford—and buy those indices as the money becomes available.

    • That way you don’t have to think about whether it is a good time to buy or not.

    • Just keep doing it on a regular schedule.

  4. Risk flag: the S&P 500 is concentrated in the “Magnificent Seven”

    • He wants to flag one risk from investing in the S&P 500 index.

    • This should not stop you from investing in the index, but you should be aware of it.

    • The “Mag Seven” stocks are: Apple, Google, Microsoft, Meta, Nvidia, Tesla, and Amazon.

    • Each is huge and represents a very high percentage of the S&P 500.

    • Combined, these seven stocks represent 30% of the S&P 500 index.

    • As far as he can tell, never in modern investing history have seven stocks represented such a high percentage of the index.

    • So when you own the S&P 500, you have big exposure to the Mag 7—30%.

    • That may be a good thing; it certainly has been good for the last several years.

    • But you should be aware that if these seven stocks underperform, it is more likely than not that the index will do poorly.

  5. The Mag 7’s outperformance has hurt professional investors

    • Professional investors running large funds have risk parameters they must follow.

    • One parameter is that you can’t own a stock above a certain percentage of your portfolio.

    • The Mag 7 are now such a high percentage of the index that portfolio managers mostly can’t overweight them because they are so big.

    • Many actually have to underweight them because of their risk parameters—not because they don’t want to overweight them, but because they can’t.

    • So as long as the Mag 7 as a group do well, chances are most actively managed funds will underperform.

  6. Midcap and small-cap stocks/indices

    • Investing in midcap or small-cap stocks or indices is up to you.

    • But as you go down in market cap, your risk tends to increase, and so does volatility.

    • For most people, he would just stick to the S&P 500 or combine it with Nasdaq.

  7. Investing overseas

    • The U.S., in his view, is the most dynamic economy in the developed world.

    • Personally, he doesn’t see a need to invest overseas.

    • He says he does not invest outside the U.S.

    • For the last decade at least, investors have done much better just by investing in the U.S., except recently.

    • He thinks that will continue over the long term.

  8. Overseas investing adds currency risk

    • Investing overseas introduces an additional risk: currency.

    • You might make money in an overseas stock and lose it in the currency.

    • Then you have to think about hedging the currency—another complication.

  9. Another reason to stick to the U.S.: tech weight

    • The info tech sector plus tech-related companies that are not technically in info tech—like Meta, Google, and Amazon—constitute over 40% of the S&P 500.

    • No other developed country is even close to that percentage.

    • So if you are positive on tech for the future, like him, it makes sense to stick to the U.S.—“It’s where the action is.”

  10. Emerging markets add other risks

    • If you get involved in emerging markets, the rule of law can be weak, which can create other problems.

    • For most people, you just don’t need that added complexity.

    • Just stick to the U.S.

  11. Individual stocks

    • Whether to buy individual stocks is up to you.

    • He would still invest most of your money in the indices.

    • But if you want to play in stocks too, take a percentage of your money—an amount you are comfortable with—and buy individual stocks.

    • His recommendation for most individuals is just to stick to the indices.

    • If you do feel the pull to own stocks, thesis creep—discussed later—is very important.

  12. Bonds: he generally does not recommend them for young/long-horizon investors

    • Most financial advisers recommend that any client put a certain percentage of money in bonds.

    • He is not one of those people.

    • If you are young or have a long investment horizon, he thinks the best thing is to put most of your money in stocks, and as he said, stock indices.

    • Over time, you will do much better just investing in stocks.

    • He admits he may be biased—he has always been a “stock jockey”—but that is what he thinks.

  13. If you are not comfortable being 100% in stocks, buy some bonds

    • For those not comfortable investing 100% in stocks, buy some bonds.

    • Here too he would use indices; there are bond indices of all types.

    • Keep it simple: buy Treasuries or an index of highly rated corporate U.S. bonds.

    • He would not buy any bonds overseas.

    • You are buying bonds for safety and to make some money.

    • Overseas bonds introduce currency risk and country risk; you don’t need that additional risk.

  14. Using a financial advisor: general points

    • Using a financial advisor is fine.

    • But with most financial advisors, you will not get his advice to mostly invest in equities.

    • At most big firms, what happens is a model: they interview you, get a lot of information, try to figure out your risk tolerance, put that into a computer, and out spits a model portfolio.

    • The model portfolio will give you some combination of stocks and bonds, and usually they advise putting around half your money in bonds.

    • What you get is a bunch of bond and stock indices and sometimes some mutual funds.

    • He generally does not like this type of investing.

  15. Problem: over-diversified advisor portfolios

    • He has gotten clients who are unhappy with their financial advisor, and he has seen the portfolios.

    • It is a “hodgepodge of everything”: large-cap stock indices, midcap indices, small-cap stock indices, some international funds, and a bunch of bond indices.

    • The client is so diversified that they don’t even know what they’re rooting for.

    • They are so diversified that they have “diversified away any hope for decent performance.”

  16. If you hire an advisor, demand simplicity

    • Make sure what you get is relatively simple.

    • A few stock indices—no more than three.

    • A few bond indices—again, no more than three.

    • That way, you know what you are investing in.

    • His motto: KISS—Keep It Simple, Stupid.

This response is AI-generated, for reference only.

Chapter 4: The Dangers of Thesis Creep — Detailed Main Points

  1. Topic and importance

    • This is “Topic three: the dangers of thesis creep.”

    • Eisman calls it a very important concept.

    • It applies mostly to those who are investing in stocks.

  2. Definition of thesis creep

    • Thesis creep is “the bane of every investor,” and he speaks from “very hard experience.”

    • It occurs when you invest in a stock and the thesis behind the stock does not work, but you keep the stock anyway.

  3. How a thesis is supposed to work

    • When you buy a stock, you buy it for a reason—a thesis.

    • Example: he buys Capital One, a bank and credit card company.

    • His thesis: the stock is cheap and credit quality is going to get better.

    • As a result, earnings estimates will go up and so will the stock.

  4. What happens when the thesis fails

    • Suppose credit quality does not get better—in fact, it gets worse.

    • Estimates go down and so does the stock.

    • He was wrong.

  5. The moment thesis creep begins

    • If he does not sell the stock because he thinks it is now lower and therefore cheaper, and “one day things will get better,” that is thesis creep.

    • In other words, thesis creep is replacing the original thesis with a new, weaker rationalization for continuing to hold a losing stock.

  6. Why thesis creep happens

    • It happens to everyone.

    • It results from people getting emotionally attached to their stocks and hating to admit they are wrong.

  7. Second example: Citigroup

    • About 10 years ago, he bought Citigroup because it was cheap and because it had a better CEO who he thought would make the company better.

    • His key data point was an improving return on equity.

  8. The thesis did not work

    • The problem was that Citigroup had a problematic franchise.

    • Bad businesses are notoriously difficult to fix.

    • Nothing improved, and his thesis was not working.

  9. He got stubborn

    • Instead of selling, he got stubborn.

    • He said to himself: “The stock is so cheap. It will work out.”

    • He did not give up until years later, after the last trading scandal.

  10. Timing and the same thesis today

    • Some people he knows own Citigroup today with exactly the same thesis he had.

    • But the company has a different CEO, and they believe she is much better.

    • They could be right—and if they are, then his thesis was eventually correct.

    • But he was betting on the wrong management team.

    • Timing is everything in investing.

  11. Investing is not always rational

    • People get attached to their stocks.

    • He gets attached to his stocks.

    • The lesson: you must try as hard as you can not to get emotionally attached, which is difficult.

  12. What to do instead

    • Always know what your thesis is.

    • Always know what data points will prove or disprove it.

  13. Everyone is vulnerable

    • At some point in your investment career, you will succumb to thesis creep.

    • Everybody does.

    • No matter how good they are, “we are all human.”

    • Just try to learn from the experience.

This response is AI-generated, for reference only.


Chapter 5: How Do I Short Stocks? — Detailed Main Points

  1. Topic

    • “Topic four: how do I short stocks and what risk do I have when I do it?”

  2. Buying a stock is simple

    • You place an order, the order goes to an exchange, it is filled, and now you own the stock.

    • If the stock goes up, you make money.

    • If the stock goes down, you lose money.

  3. Key point about long positions: risk decreases as the stock declines

    • Eisman stresses: “as the stock price declines, my risk decreases as well.”

    • He repeats: “as the stock declines, my risk decreases.”

    • This sounds weird but is true.

  4. Example of how long-position risk shrinks

    • Suppose you have $100,000 and buy 25 different stocks, all the same size.

    • Each stock is a 4% position, or **$4,000** in size ($100,000 ÷ 25).

    • Simplify: stock A gets cut in half, but all other stocks go up so the portfolio is still worth $100,000.

    • You are even.

    • Stock A is now $2,000, or a 2% position.

    • The remaining 24 stocks are about 4.083% each, or about $4,083.

    • Stock A’s performance hurt, but it is now only a 2% position.

    • From a risk perspective, your risk in stock A is lower because the position is smaller.

  5. What shorting a stock means

    • Shorting a stock means you are betting the stock will go down.

  6. Mechanics of shorting

    • First, you borrow the stock from someone who actually owns it.

    • You pay the owner a fee for borrowing the stock.

    • You then sell the stock and pocket the cash.

  7. How you make money shorting: example

    • You short a stock at **$100**: you borrow the stock and sell it at $100, so you have $100 in your pocket.

    • The stock declines to $50, and you decide you’ve had enough.

    • You buy it back at $50 and give the stock back to the owner.

    • You sold at $100 and bought back at $50, so you made $50, less the fee you paid for borrowing the stock.

  8. First thing to know: borrowing is usually seamless

    • The process of borrowing the stock is “pretty seamless.”

    • When you put in the order to short the stock, the borrowing happens automatically through a trading desk.

  9. Second thing: the cost of borrow can vary

    • For a large, liquid stock, the cost to borrow is low.

    • For an illiquid stock, or an illiquid stock that is heavily shorted, the cost to borrow can be very, very high—even prohibitive.

    • He has seen borrowing costs in excess of 20% to 30% annually.

    • That means you need to make money on the short pretty quickly.

    • If you hold the short for a year, you need to make more than the 20–30% fee you are paying.

  10. Third thing: shorting has risks that generally do not occur on the long side

    • One key risk involves heavily shorted stocks.

    • A “heavily shorted stock” means a high percentage of the outstanding stock is heavily shorted.

    • Information like that is fairly easy to ascertain.

  11. Short squeeze: what it is

    • If you get involved with a heavily shorted stock, you can be subject to a short squeeze.

    • Suppose positive news comes out about the stock and people start to buy.

    • Given that the stock is illiquid, not much stock trades.

    • On good news, the stock starts to go up—and given the illiquidity, it could go up a lot.

    • The shorts start to “freak” and cover, meaning they are buying the stock too.

    • So the stock could go up much, much more than the importance of the news.

  12. Fourth reason short squeezes can get ugly: position size moves against you

    • As said before, when a long goes against you, the position becomes smaller.

    • So the risk is smaller because it is now a smaller percentage of your portfolio.

    • The opposite happens in a short.

    • Suppose you short a stock and it is 4% of your portfolio.

    • If the stock doubles, it is now an 8% position.

    • In a long, you can only lose what you invest.

    • In a short, your potential loss is theoretically unlimited—the stock can keep going up.

  13. Why hedge funds are forced to cover in a short squeeze

    • In a short, if the stock goes up on you, the risk profile changes.

    • The position becomes bigger, so the risk is bigger.

    • That is why in a short squeeze, hedge funds are forced to cover.

    • As the stock goes up, the size of the position becomes bigger and bigger.

    • Risk managers at hedge funds contact the person in charge of the position and order him or her to reduce it.

    • So they are forced to cover even though they don’t want to—which makes the short squeeze even worse.

  14. Lesson: shorting heavily shorted stocks can be dangerous

    • Shorting a heavily shorted stock can be dangerous regardless of how good your investment case is.

    • He knows this only from “painful, and I mean really painful, experience.”

  15. Shorting requires an entirely different mindset

    • Shorting stocks requires a different mindset.

    • Some people have problems shorting stocks because they don’t like rooting against a company.

    • Eisman says he does not have that problem.

  16. Future topic

    • What makes a good short, and when and why shorts don’t work, will be explored in future podcasts.

This response is AI-generated, for reference only.

W


No comments: