Chapter 8: Safety Stocks, Cyclical Stocks, & Growth Stocks — Detailed Main Points
Topic seven: What are safety stocks, cyclical stocks, and growth stocks?
Eisman notes that business shows often say “risk is up, so investors are reallocating to safety stocks.”
He asks what that actually means.
Common definitions of “safety” sectors
Generally, when investors speak about safety sectors, they mean:
Consumer staples
Healthcare
Utilities
Sometimes REITs
Almost all parts of tech are viewed as growth, not safety.
Sectors like industrials and financials are viewed as cyclicals, meaning heavily dependent on the economy.
These are gross oversimplifications
Within the 11 S&P 500 sectors, there are safety, cyclical, and growth subsectors.
The U.S. economy has become so dynamic that sectors once viewed as safe are not so safe anymore.
His three-category framework
Growth: info tech and communication services.
Cyclical: consumer discretionary, energy, financials, industrials, and materials.
Safety: consumer staples, healthcare, real estate, and utilities.
He calls this a gross oversimplification, but says oversimplifications can illuminate.
Expected performance pattern
When times are good and the market is soaring, growth and cyclicals should do better than safety.
When recession or war fears mount and the market corrects, safety should outperform growth and cyclicals.
Recent 2025 market test: correction and rally
On February 19, 2025, the S&P 500 peaked at 6,144.
Nervousness about a trade war took hold; President Trump announced “Liberation Day” on April 2.
From February 19 to April 8, the S&P declined to 4,983—a 16% point-to-point decline.
After April 8, the market staged an impressive rally, with the S&P climbing to 5,985.
From the 52-week low on April 8, that was a 20% increase.
The two periods examined: February 19–April 8 and April 9–May 16.
Sector performance during the correction and rally
S&P 500: down 16%, then up 20%.
Communication services: down 21%, then up 19%.
Consumer discretionary: down 24%, then up 24%.
Consumer staples: down only 8%, then up 8%.
Energy: down 16%, then up 11%.
Financials: down 16%, then up 17%.
Healthcare: down 9%, then flat.
Industrials: down 16%, then up 23%.
Info tech: down 26%, then up 31%.
Materials: down 17%, then up 17%.
Real estate: down 12%, then up 13%.
Utilities: down 9%, then up 12%.
Simple math warning
If you go down 20% and then go up 20%, you are not even.
Theory largely held
In bad times, consumer staples outperformed everybody else.
In good times, staples tended to underperform everybody else.
During the correction, every sector was down—so even if you piled into safety sectors, you still lost money, just less money.
Safety did outperform cyclicals and growth.
The reverse happened during the rally after April 8.
Healthcare was an exception
Healthcare outperformed during the correction and lagged during the rally.
But unlike other safety stocks, healthcare did not go up during the rally—it was flat.
Why? During the rally, President Trump announced that the U.S. government, through Medicare and Medicaid, would only pay the lowest price paid by other countries for drugs.
That was very negative news for the sector, so healthcare did not participate in the rally.
S&P 500 sector weights as of June 18, 2025
Info tech: 31%—the biggest.
Financials: 14%.
Healthcare: 11%.
Consumer discretionary: 10%.
Industrials: 9%.
Communication services: 7%.
Consumer staples: 5%.
Utilities: 3%.
Energy: 3%.
Real estate: 2%.
Materials: 1%.
Info tech’s true importance is greater than 31%
A few years ago, S&P rejiggered its categories.
Meta and Google were moved from info tech to communication services.
Amazon is in consumer discretionary, even though its most profitable business is cloud storage.
If Meta, Google, and Amazon were put into info tech, the weight would climb from 31% to over 40%.
No other developed country has tech and tech-related companies at over 40% of the market.
By contrast, Europe’s biggest three sectors are financials at 25%, industrials at 18%, and info tech at 16%.
So if you are bullish on tech for the long term, like Eisman, stick to the U.S.
Sector-by-sector flavor
1. Info tech — 31%
By far the biggest sector.
Mostly growth, composed of hardware and software, with subsectors within them.
Examples: Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia.
Valuation tools: P/E and EV/EBITDA; discounted cash flow for growth companies with no earnings.
Growth stocks tend to get very high valuations.
2. Financials — 14%
Composed of banks, investment banks, asset managers, specialty finance, life insurance, property and casualty insurance, and payments companies like Visa and Mastercard.
Banks are the largest component.
Traditional parts like banks tend to be valued on price-to-tangible-book-value.
Banks and life insurance companies tend to be viewed as cyclical.
Property and casualty is viewed as the safety part of the traditional group.
Payments is viewed as growth.
Payment companies like Visa and Mastercard are not valued on price-to-tangible-book but on a P/E basis and tend to have high P/Es; Visa’s P/E is in the high 20s.
3. Healthcare — 11%
Biotech is a growth subsector.
The rest of healthcare is viewed somewhat as safety, or at least it once was.
For years, pharma was “sleepy” with old drug pipelines; some companies still are like that.
Johnson & Johnson is viewed as a quasi-staple.
The last five years have seen a resurgence in new drugs such as Ozempic and Mounjaro and some Alzheimer’s drugs.
Growth of some companies like Eli Lilly has surged, so much of pharma is now viewed as a growth area.
Big risk: politics, because Medicare and Medicaid pay for so many drugs; the government may regulate pricing more, as recently learned.
Generally P/E is used, sometimes EV/EBITDA.
In pharma and biotech, analysts try to estimate the future profitability of new drugs and the value of a drug pipeline—not easy.
4. Consumer discretionary — 10%
Not much safety here.
Divided between growth, such as Amazon and Booking, versus cyclical areas like homebuilders, old-fashioned retail, and autos.
5. Communication services — he says 9% in this section
Note: earlier in the chapter he listed communication services at 7%.
S&P rejiggered categories, moving certain tech companies like Google and Meta from info tech into communications.
Today communications has growth: Google, Netflix, Meta, Reddit, Snapchat.
It also has cyclicals like IMAX and advertising companies like Omnicom.
Communications used to have big safety plays like traditional media and cable companies.
But media and cable dynamics have been hurt by cord cutting and streaming, so they are no longer viewed as safety but as deteriorating businesses.
Lesson: nothing lasts forever.
6. Industrials — he says 8% in this section
Note: earlier in the chapter he listed industrials at 9%.
Highly cyclical sector.
But growth dynamics of some subsectors have improved.
Companies like Eaton are part of the reindustrialization of America story, and Eaton’s growth rate has improved dramatically over the last few years.
Still, the sector is generally viewed as cyclical.
7. Consumer staples — he says 6% in this section
Note: earlier in the chapter he listed staples at 5%.
Typical stocks: Clorox and Procter & Gamble.
This is a safety group, but not quite as safe as it once was; it seems more competitive.
Companies here tend to be steady but slow-growth stories—often low single digits.
Despite more competition almost everywhere in staples, it is still viewed as a safety sector, which is why it outperformed in April when everyone was petrified of a trade war.
Despite slow growth, the sector tends to get high multiples—higher than he thinks they deserve.
Example of changed competition: the beauty industry used to be extremely consistent earnings run by very large companies.
Today, new makeup companies, celebrities, and influencers have upended the industry.
Many new companies have been very successful and have hurt the performance of more traditional companies.
8. Energy — 3%
Once a super-important group; in the 1970s it was one of the larger groups in the S&P 500.
Now only 3%.
Very cyclical, with the exception of alternative energy, mostly solar.
Traditional energy stocks’ earnings are tied to the price of oil, which is virtually impossible to predict and incredibly volatile.
Some investors avoid the sector because they don’t want to predict oil prices; Eisman is one of those people.
Solar was viewed as a growth sector and did exceptionally well during the pandemic.
But solar companies, especially those selling panels to consumers, turned out to be very sensitive to interest rates.
It costs about $30,000 to put a solar system on a roof; most people finance it.
During COVID, they could finance at very low rates; with much higher rates, sales have dried up.
The new Trump administration does not favor solar, which is why solar stocks have performed poorly this year.
9. Real estate
Once viewed mostly as a safety group, with one growth subsector: data centers and cell towers.
One major group, office buildings, was also viewed as fairly safe but has gone through a tough period as the value of office space has gone down.
Some people argue that may now be over.
10. Utilities
Definitely a safety group.
Highly regulated, so future profitability is easy to predict.
Decent P/E generally in the high teens.
Also valued on its dividend yield.
Bottom line
There are still safety sectors out there.
But some of them are not quite as safe as they once were.
Topic seven: What are safety stocks, cyclical stocks, and growth stocks?
Eisman notes that business shows often say “risk is up, so investors are reallocating to safety stocks.”
He asks what that actually means.
Common definitions of “safety” sectors
Generally, when investors speak about safety sectors, they mean:
Consumer staples
Healthcare
Utilities
Sometimes REITs
Almost all parts of tech are viewed as growth, not safety.
Sectors like industrials and financials are viewed as cyclicals, meaning heavily dependent on the economy.
These are gross oversimplifications
Within the 11 S&P 500 sectors, there are safety, cyclical, and growth subsectors.
The U.S. economy has become so dynamic that sectors once viewed as safe are not so safe anymore.
His three-category framework
Growth: info tech and communication services.
Cyclical: consumer discretionary, energy, financials, industrials, and materials.
Safety: consumer staples, healthcare, real estate, and utilities.
He calls this a gross oversimplification, but says oversimplifications can illuminate.
Expected performance pattern
When times are good and the market is soaring, growth and cyclicals should do better than safety.
When recession or war fears mount and the market corrects, safety should outperform growth and cyclicals.
Recent 2025 market test: correction and rally
On February 19, 2025, the S&P 500 peaked at 6,144.
Nervousness about a trade war took hold; President Trump announced “Liberation Day” on April 2.
From February 19 to April 8, the S&P declined to 4,983—a 16% point-to-point decline.
After April 8, the market staged an impressive rally, with the S&P climbing to 5,985.
From the 52-week low on April 8, that was a 20% increase.
The two periods examined: February 19–April 8 and April 9–May 16.
Sector performance during the correction and rally
S&P 500: down 16%, then up 20%.
Communication services: down 21%, then up 19%.
Consumer discretionary: down 24%, then up 24%.
Consumer staples: down only 8%, then up 8%.
Energy: down 16%, then up 11%.
Financials: down 16%, then up 17%.
Healthcare: down 9%, then flat.
Industrials: down 16%, then up 23%.
Info tech: down 26%, then up 31%.
Materials: down 17%, then up 17%.
Real estate: down 12%, then up 13%.
Utilities: down 9%, then up 12%.
Simple math warning
If you go down 20% and then go up 20%, you are not even.
Theory largely held
In bad times, consumer staples outperformed everybody else.
In good times, staples tended to underperform everybody else.
During the correction, every sector was down—so even if you piled into safety sectors, you still lost money, just less money.
Safety did outperform cyclicals and growth.
The reverse happened during the rally after April 8.
Healthcare was an exception
Healthcare outperformed during the correction and lagged during the rally.
But unlike other safety stocks, healthcare did not go up during the rally—it was flat.
Why? During the rally, President Trump announced that the U.S. government, through Medicare and Medicaid, would only pay the lowest price paid by other countries for drugs.
That was very negative news for the sector, so healthcare did not participate in the rally.
S&P 500 sector weights as of June 18, 2025
Info tech: 31%—the biggest.
Financials: 14%.
Healthcare: 11%.
Consumer discretionary: 10%.
Industrials: 9%.
Communication services: 7%.
Consumer staples: 5%.
Utilities: 3%.
Energy: 3%.
Real estate: 2%.
Materials: 1%.
Info tech’s true importance is greater than 31%
A few years ago, S&P rejiggered its categories.
Meta and Google were moved from info tech to communication services.
Amazon is in consumer discretionary, even though its most profitable business is cloud storage.
If Meta, Google, and Amazon were put into info tech, the weight would climb from 31% to over 40%.
No other developed country has tech and tech-related companies at over 40% of the market.
By contrast, Europe’s biggest three sectors are financials at 25%, industrials at 18%, and info tech at 16%.
So if you are bullish on tech for the long term, like Eisman, stick to the U.S.
Sector-by-sector flavor
1. Info tech — 31%
By far the biggest sector.
Mostly growth, composed of hardware and software, with subsectors within them.
Examples: Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia.
Valuation tools: P/E and EV/EBITDA; discounted cash flow for growth companies with no earnings.
Growth stocks tend to get very high valuations.
2. Financials — 14%
Composed of banks, investment banks, asset managers, specialty finance, life insurance, property and casualty insurance, and payments companies like Visa and Mastercard.
Banks are the largest component.
Traditional parts like banks tend to be valued on price-to-tangible-book-value.
Banks and life insurance companies tend to be viewed as cyclical.
Property and casualty is viewed as the safety part of the traditional group.
Payments is viewed as growth.
Payment companies like Visa and Mastercard are not valued on price-to-tangible-book but on a P/E basis and tend to have high P/Es; Visa’s P/E is in the high 20s.
3. Healthcare — 11%
Biotech is a growth subsector.
The rest of healthcare is viewed somewhat as safety, or at least it once was.
For years, pharma was “sleepy” with old drug pipelines; some companies still are like that.
Johnson & Johnson is viewed as a quasi-staple.
The last five years have seen a resurgence in new drugs such as Ozempic and Mounjaro and some Alzheimer’s drugs.
Growth of some companies like Eli Lilly has surged, so much of pharma is now viewed as a growth area.
Big risk: politics, because Medicare and Medicaid pay for so many drugs; the government may regulate pricing more, as recently learned.
Generally P/E is used, sometimes EV/EBITDA.
In pharma and biotech, analysts try to estimate the future profitability of new drugs and the value of a drug pipeline—not easy.
4. Consumer discretionary — 10%
Not much safety here.
Divided between growth, such as Amazon and Booking, versus cyclical areas like homebuilders, old-fashioned retail, and autos.
5. Communication services — he says 9% in this section
Note: earlier in the chapter he listed communication services at 7%.
S&P rejiggered categories, moving certain tech companies like Google and Meta from info tech into communications.
Today communications has growth: Google, Netflix, Meta, Reddit, Snapchat.
It also has cyclicals like IMAX and advertising companies like Omnicom.
Communications used to have big safety plays like traditional media and cable companies.
But media and cable dynamics have been hurt by cord cutting and streaming, so they are no longer viewed as safety but as deteriorating businesses.
Lesson: nothing lasts forever.
6. Industrials — he says 8% in this section
Note: earlier in the chapter he listed industrials at 9%.
Highly cyclical sector.
But growth dynamics of some subsectors have improved.
Companies like Eaton are part of the reindustrialization of America story, and Eaton’s growth rate has improved dramatically over the last few years.
Still, the sector is generally viewed as cyclical.
7. Consumer staples — he says 6% in this section
Note: earlier in the chapter he listed staples at 5%.
Typical stocks: Clorox and Procter & Gamble.
This is a safety group, but not quite as safe as it once was; it seems more competitive.
Companies here tend to be steady but slow-growth stories—often low single digits.
Despite more competition almost everywhere in staples, it is still viewed as a safety sector, which is why it outperformed in April when everyone was petrified of a trade war.
Despite slow growth, the sector tends to get high multiples—higher than he thinks they deserve.
Example of changed competition: the beauty industry used to be extremely consistent earnings run by very large companies.
Today, new makeup companies, celebrities, and influencers have upended the industry.
Many new companies have been very successful and have hurt the performance of more traditional companies.
8. Energy — 3%
Once a super-important group; in the 1970s it was one of the larger groups in the S&P 500.
Now only 3%.
Very cyclical, with the exception of alternative energy, mostly solar.
Traditional energy stocks’ earnings are tied to the price of oil, which is virtually impossible to predict and incredibly volatile.
Some investors avoid the sector because they don’t want to predict oil prices; Eisman is one of those people.
Solar was viewed as a growth sector and did exceptionally well during the pandemic.
But solar companies, especially those selling panels to consumers, turned out to be very sensitive to interest rates.
It costs about $30,000 to put a solar system on a roof; most people finance it.
During COVID, they could finance at very low rates; with much higher rates, sales have dried up.
The new Trump administration does not favor solar, which is why solar stocks have performed poorly this year.
9. Real estate
Once viewed mostly as a safety group, with one growth subsector: data centers and cell towers.
One major group, office buildings, was also viewed as fairly safe but has gone through a tough period as the value of office space has gone down.
Some people argue that may now be over.
10. Utilities
Definitely a safety group.
Highly regulated, so future profitability is easy to predict.
Decent P/E generally in the high teens.
Also valued on its dividend yield.
Bottom line
There are still safety sectors out there.
But some of them are not quite as safe as they once were.
Chapter 9: How Interest Rate Changes Impact the Stock Market — Detailed Main Points
Topic
“Topic eight: how do changes in interest rates impact the stock market and the valuation of companies?”
Changes in interest rates have a large impact on stocks, particularly growth stocks and financial stocks.
The simple version
The simple conclusion is: when rates go up, stocks go down; when rates go down, stocks go up.
But Eisman says it is not that simple.
You always have to ask: which rates—short-term or long-term?
Rates as a proxy for the economy
First, he discusses rates as a proxy for the economy.
The Fed controls only the Fed funds rate
The Federal Reserve only controls the Fed funds rate.
That is the overnight rate that banks lend to one another.
He repeats: the Fed only controls the Fed funds rate, the overnight rate banks lend to each other.
That is very, very short term.
The Fed does not control any other interest rate. The market does.
The yield curve
When people speak about the yield curve, they are drawing a line from short-term rates to long-term rates.
Most of the time, long-term rates are higher than short-term rates.
Why? Because it is riskier to lend long term than short term.
That is why the yield curve is normally positively sloped.
Why the yield curve can invert
When people get nervous about the economy, they tend to sell stocks and use the money to buy long-term bonds to park their money.
That causes the price of long-term bonds to go up and their yield to go down.
Note: bond yields are inversely related to price.
When price goes up, yield goes down.
When price goes down, yield goes up.
So in periods of nervousness, long-term rates can collapse while the Fed has not yet cut rates at the short end.
The yield curve can become inverted, meaning short-term rates are higher than long-term rates.
An inversion is taken as a sign that investors are worried the economy is going into recession.
The yield curve is not a perfect predictor
The yield curve is not a perfect predictor of recessions.
Sometimes it is right, sometimes it is wrong.
It is more of a gauge of how people are feeling about the economy.
Tangent: banks and the yield curve
Eisman says the yield curve is more important than anything else for banks.
He oversimplifies to make the point.
A bank is a levered business model.
It takes deposits and lends them out.
On checking accounts, it pays nothing.
On savings accounts, it pays an interest rate tied to short-term rates.
It takes that money and lends medium to long term.
So a bank is borrowing at the short end of the curve and lending at the medium-to-long end.
The steeper the yield curve—the bigger the difference between short-term and long-term rates—the bigger the bank’s net interest margin and the more money it makes.
Since net interest income is the biggest revenue item for most banks, the shape of the yield curve is crucial for determining profitability.
Back to rates and stocks: rising rates are not always bad
Rising rates are not always bad for stocks.
If—and it is a big if—long-term rates are rising because the economy is strong,
and long-term rates are not increasing too much,
and there is no threat of inflation on the horizon,
then rising rates are not bad.
When are rising rates bad and why?
Rising rates are bad if there is inflation and the Fed is threatening to raise rates a lot, or is actually doing so.
Then stocks go down.
First reason higher rates hurt stocks: higher cost of money
By raising rates, the Fed is increasing the cost of money.
It becomes more expensive for individuals and companies to borrow money.
That will slow the economy.
People begin to worry that not only will the economy slow, but a recession could occur.
2022 example
That is why the market had a big correction in 2022.
The S&P was down 18% for the year.
The Fed was aggressively raising rates because of rampant inflation.
Investors were worried there would be a recession.
Recessions hurt company earnings, and that kills stock prices.
By the way, the market was wrong—there was no recession.
Second reason higher rates hurt stocks: discounted cash flow
When he discussed how to value companies, one method was discounted cash flow (DCF).
He does not like that method much because there are too many variables to model far into the future.
But he admits that in principle it is the right way to value stocks.
Assume that when someone models out a company for DCF, all the numbers are correct by some miracle.
Then you still have to choose a discount rate to discount the cash flow back to the present.
If interest rates are going up, the discount rate you once chose is too low.
Every time rates go up, you have to increase the discount rate in your model.
Simple math: in a DCF analysis, when the discount rate increases, the valuation result goes down, and vice versa.
That is why growth stocks tend to go down a lot when interest rates go up, because DCF is often used to value growth stocks.
Different sectors are impacted differently by rate movements
Generally speaking, companies with staple-like characteristics—slow growth but very stable earnings—are impacted the least by changes in interest rates.
Growth stocks are impacted a lot, again because of the DCF mechanism.
A growth stock, especially a hyper-growth story, has potentially big earnings in the outer years.
In DCF, when the numbers get big in the outer years, changes in the discount rate impact the valuation number a lot.
So generally, when rates go up or are going up:
Growth stocks will go down the most.
Staples will go down the least, and staples could even go up as people reallocate.
Why stocks go up when rates go down
As for why stocks go up when rates go down: just reverse everything he just said.
Transition
That concludes his explanation of interest rates and stocks in the master class.
No comments:
Post a Comment