Sunday, 22 November 2026

Chapter 8: Safety Stocks, Cyclical Stocks & Growth Stocks and Chapter 9: How Interest Rate Changes Impact the Stock Market




Chapter 8: Safety Stocks, Cyclical Stocks, & Growth Stocks — Detailed Main Points

  1. Topic seven: What are safety stocks, cyclical stocks, and growth stocks?

    • Eisman notes that business shows often say “risk is up, so investors are reallocating to safety stocks.”

    • He asks what that actually means.

  2. Common definitions of “safety” sectors

    • Generally, when investors speak about safety sectors, they mean:

      • Consumer staples

      • Healthcare

      • Utilities

      • Sometimes REITs

    • Almost all parts of tech are viewed as growth, not safety.

    • Sectors like industrials and financials are viewed as cyclicals, meaning heavily dependent on the economy.

  3. These are gross oversimplifications

    • Within the 11 S&P 500 sectors, there are safety, cyclical, and growth subsectors.

    • The U.S. economy has become so dynamic that sectors once viewed as safe are not so safe anymore.

  4. His three-category framework

    • Growth: info tech and communication services.

    • Cyclical: consumer discretionary, energy, financials, industrials, and materials.

    • Safety: consumer staples, healthcare, real estate, and utilities.

    • He calls this a gross oversimplification, but says oversimplifications can illuminate.

  5. Expected performance pattern

    • When times are good and the market is soaring, growth and cyclicals should do better than safety.

    • When recession or war fears mount and the market corrects, safety should outperform growth and cyclicals.

  6. Recent 2025 market test: correction and rally

    • On February 19, 2025, the S&P 500 peaked at 6,144.

    • Nervousness about a trade war took hold; President Trump announced “Liberation Day” on April 2.

    • From February 19 to April 8, the S&P declined to 4,983—a 16% point-to-point decline.

    • After April 8, the market staged an impressive rally, with the S&P climbing to 5,985.

    • From the 52-week low on April 8, that was a 20% increase.

    • The two periods examined: February 19–April 8 and April 9–May 16.

  7. Sector performance during the correction and rally

    • S&P 500: down 16%, then up 20%.

    • Communication services: down 21%, then up 19%.

    • Consumer discretionary: down 24%, then up 24%.

    • Consumer staples: down only 8%, then up 8%.

    • Energy: down 16%, then up 11%.

    • Financials: down 16%, then up 17%.

    • Healthcare: down 9%, then flat.

    • Industrials: down 16%, then up 23%.

    • Info tech: down 26%, then up 31%.

    • Materials: down 17%, then up 17%.

    • Real estate: down 12%, then up 13%.

    • Utilities: down 9%, then up 12%.

  8. Simple math warning

    • If you go down 20% and then go up 20%, you are not even.

  9. Theory largely held

    • In bad times, consumer staples outperformed everybody else.

    • In good times, staples tended to underperform everybody else.

    • During the correction, every sector was down—so even if you piled into safety sectors, you still lost money, just less money.

    • Safety did outperform cyclicals and growth.

    • The reverse happened during the rally after April 8.

  10. Healthcare was an exception

    • Healthcare outperformed during the correction and lagged during the rally.

    • But unlike other safety stocks, healthcare did not go up during the rally—it was flat.

    • Why? During the rally, President Trump announced that the U.S. government, through Medicare and Medicaid, would only pay the lowest price paid by other countries for drugs.

    • That was very negative news for the sector, so healthcare did not participate in the rally.

  11. S&P 500 sector weights as of June 18, 2025

    • Info tech: 31%—the biggest.

    • Financials: 14%.

    • Healthcare: 11%.

    • Consumer discretionary: 10%.

    • Industrials: 9%.

    • Communication services: 7%.

    • Consumer staples: 5%.

    • Utilities: 3%.

    • Energy: 3%.

    • Real estate: 2%.

    • Materials: 1%.

  12. Info tech’s true importance is greater than 31%

    • A few years ago, S&P rejiggered its categories.

    • Meta and Google were moved from info tech to communication services.

    • Amazon is in consumer discretionary, even though its most profitable business is cloud storage.

    • If Meta, Google, and Amazon were put into info tech, the weight would climb from 31% to over 40%.

    • No other developed country has tech and tech-related companies at over 40% of the market.

    • By contrast, Europe’s biggest three sectors are financials at 25%, industrials at 18%, and info tech at 16%.

    • So if you are bullish on tech for the long term, like Eisman, stick to the U.S.

  13. Sector-by-sector flavor

    1. Info tech — 31%

    • By far the biggest sector.

    • Mostly growth, composed of hardware and software, with subsectors within them.

    • Examples: Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia.

    • Valuation tools: P/E and EV/EBITDA; discounted cash flow for growth companies with no earnings.

    • Growth stocks tend to get very high valuations.

    2. Financials — 14%

    • Composed of banks, investment banks, asset managers, specialty finance, life insurance, property and casualty insurance, and payments companies like Visa and Mastercard.

    • Banks are the largest component.

    • Traditional parts like banks tend to be valued on price-to-tangible-book-value.

    • Banks and life insurance companies tend to be viewed as cyclical.

    • Property and casualty is viewed as the safety part of the traditional group.

    • Payments is viewed as growth.

    • Payment companies like Visa and Mastercard are not valued on price-to-tangible-book but on a P/E basis and tend to have high P/Es; Visa’s P/E is in the high 20s.

    3. Healthcare — 11%

    • Biotech is a growth subsector.

    • The rest of healthcare is viewed somewhat as safety, or at least it once was.

    • For years, pharma was “sleepy” with old drug pipelines; some companies still are like that.

    • Johnson & Johnson is viewed as a quasi-staple.

    • The last five years have seen a resurgence in new drugs such as Ozempic and Mounjaro and some Alzheimer’s drugs.

    • Growth of some companies like Eli Lilly has surged, so much of pharma is now viewed as a growth area.

    • Big risk: politics, because Medicare and Medicaid pay for so many drugs; the government may regulate pricing more, as recently learned.

    • Generally P/E is used, sometimes EV/EBITDA.

    • In pharma and biotech, analysts try to estimate the future profitability of new drugs and the value of a drug pipeline—not easy.

    4. Consumer discretionary — 10%

    • Not much safety here.

    • Divided between growth, such as Amazon and Booking, versus cyclical areas like homebuilders, old-fashioned retail, and autos.

    5. Communication services — he says 9% in this section

    • Note: earlier in the chapter he listed communication services at 7%.

    • S&P rejiggered categories, moving certain tech companies like Google and Meta from info tech into communications.

    • Today communications has growth: Google, Netflix, Meta, Reddit, Snapchat.

    • It also has cyclicals like IMAX and advertising companies like Omnicom.

    • Communications used to have big safety plays like traditional media and cable companies.

    • But media and cable dynamics have been hurt by cord cutting and streaming, so they are no longer viewed as safety but as deteriorating businesses.

    • Lesson: nothing lasts forever.

    6. Industrials — he says 8% in this section

    • Note: earlier in the chapter he listed industrials at 9%.

    • Highly cyclical sector.

    • But growth dynamics of some subsectors have improved.

    • Companies like Eaton are part of the reindustrialization of America story, and Eaton’s growth rate has improved dramatically over the last few years.

    • Still, the sector is generally viewed as cyclical.

    7. Consumer staples — he says 6% in this section

    • Note: earlier in the chapter he listed staples at 5%.

    • Typical stocks: Clorox and Procter & Gamble.

    • This is a safety group, but not quite as safe as it once was; it seems more competitive.

    • Companies here tend to be steady but slow-growth stories—often low single digits.

    • Despite more competition almost everywhere in staples, it is still viewed as a safety sector, which is why it outperformed in April when everyone was petrified of a trade war.

    • Despite slow growth, the sector tends to get high multiples—higher than he thinks they deserve.

    • Example of changed competition: the beauty industry used to be extremely consistent earnings run by very large companies.

    • Today, new makeup companies, celebrities, and influencers have upended the industry.

    • Many new companies have been very successful and have hurt the performance of more traditional companies.

    8. Energy — 3%

    • Once a super-important group; in the 1970s it was one of the larger groups in the S&P 500.

    • Now only 3%.

    • Very cyclical, with the exception of alternative energy, mostly solar.

    • Traditional energy stocks’ earnings are tied to the price of oil, which is virtually impossible to predict and incredibly volatile.

    • Some investors avoid the sector because they don’t want to predict oil prices; Eisman is one of those people.

    • Solar was viewed as a growth sector and did exceptionally well during the pandemic.

    • But solar companies, especially those selling panels to consumers, turned out to be very sensitive to interest rates.

    • It costs about $30,000 to put a solar system on a roof; most people finance it.

    • During COVID, they could finance at very low rates; with much higher rates, sales have dried up.

    • The new Trump administration does not favor solar, which is why solar stocks have performed poorly this year.

    9. Real estate

    • Once viewed mostly as a safety group, with one growth subsector: data centers and cell towers.

    • One major group, office buildings, was also viewed as fairly safe but has gone through a tough period as the value of office space has gone down.

    • Some people argue that may now be over.

    10. Utilities

    • Definitely a safety group.

    • Highly regulated, so future profitability is easy to predict.

    • Decent P/E generally in the high teens.

    • Also valued on its dividend yield.

  14. Bottom line

    • There are still safety sectors out there.

    • But some of them are not quite as safe as they once were.


Chapter 9: How Interest Rate Changes Impact the Stock Market — Detailed Main Points

  1. Topic

    • “Topic eight: how do changes in interest rates impact the stock market and the valuation of companies?”

    • Changes in interest rates have a large impact on stocks, particularly growth stocks and financial stocks.

  2. The simple version

    • The simple conclusion is: when rates go up, stocks go down; when rates go down, stocks go up.

    • But Eisman says it is not that simple.

    • You always have to ask: which rates—short-term or long-term?

  3. Rates as a proxy for the economy

    • First, he discusses rates as a proxy for the economy.

  4. The Fed controls only the Fed funds rate

    • The Federal Reserve only controls the Fed funds rate.

    • That is the overnight rate that banks lend to one another.

    • He repeats: the Fed only controls the Fed funds rate, the overnight rate banks lend to each other.

    • That is very, very short term.

    • The Fed does not control any other interest rate. The market does.

  5. The yield curve

    • When people speak about the yield curve, they are drawing a line from short-term rates to long-term rates.

    • Most of the time, long-term rates are higher than short-term rates.

    • Why? Because it is riskier to lend long term than short term.

    • That is why the yield curve is normally positively sloped.

  6. Why the yield curve can invert

    • When people get nervous about the economy, they tend to sell stocks and use the money to buy long-term bonds to park their money.

    • That causes the price of long-term bonds to go up and their yield to go down.

    • Note: bond yields are inversely related to price.

      • When price goes up, yield goes down.

      • When price goes down, yield goes up.

    • So in periods of nervousness, long-term rates can collapse while the Fed has not yet cut rates at the short end.

    • The yield curve can become inverted, meaning short-term rates are higher than long-term rates.

    • An inversion is taken as a sign that investors are worried the economy is going into recession.

  7. The yield curve is not a perfect predictor

    • The yield curve is not a perfect predictor of recessions.

    • Sometimes it is right, sometimes it is wrong.

    • It is more of a gauge of how people are feeling about the economy.

  8. Tangent: banks and the yield curve

    • Eisman says the yield curve is more important than anything else for banks.

    • He oversimplifies to make the point.

    • A bank is a levered business model.

    • It takes deposits and lends them out.

    • On checking accounts, it pays nothing.

    • On savings accounts, it pays an interest rate tied to short-term rates.

    • It takes that money and lends medium to long term.

    • So a bank is borrowing at the short end of the curve and lending at the medium-to-long end.

    • The steeper the yield curve—the bigger the difference between short-term and long-term rates—the bigger the bank’s net interest margin and the more money it makes.

    • Since net interest income is the biggest revenue item for most banks, the shape of the yield curve is crucial for determining profitability.

  9. Back to rates and stocks: rising rates are not always bad

    • Rising rates are not always bad for stocks.

    • If—and it is a big if—long-term rates are rising because the economy is strong,

    • and long-term rates are not increasing too much,

    • and there is no threat of inflation on the horizon,

    • then rising rates are not bad.

  10. When are rising rates bad and why?

    • Rising rates are bad if there is inflation and the Fed is threatening to raise rates a lot, or is actually doing so.

    • Then stocks go down.

  11. First reason higher rates hurt stocks: higher cost of money

    • By raising rates, the Fed is increasing the cost of money.

    • It becomes more expensive for individuals and companies to borrow money.

    • That will slow the economy.

    • People begin to worry that not only will the economy slow, but a recession could occur.

  12. 2022 example

    • That is why the market had a big correction in 2022.

    • The S&P was down 18% for the year.

    • The Fed was aggressively raising rates because of rampant inflation.

    • Investors were worried there would be a recession.

    • Recessions hurt company earnings, and that kills stock prices.

    • By the way, the market was wrong—there was no recession.

  13. Second reason higher rates hurt stocks: discounted cash flow

    • When he discussed how to value companies, one method was discounted cash flow (DCF).

    • He does not like that method much because there are too many variables to model far into the future.

    • But he admits that in principle it is the right way to value stocks.

    • Assume that when someone models out a company for DCF, all the numbers are correct by some miracle.

    • Then you still have to choose a discount rate to discount the cash flow back to the present.

    • If interest rates are going up, the discount rate you once chose is too low.

    • Every time rates go up, you have to increase the discount rate in your model.

    • Simple math: in a DCF analysis, when the discount rate increases, the valuation result goes down, and vice versa.

    • That is why growth stocks tend to go down a lot when interest rates go up, because DCF is often used to value growth stocks.

  14. Different sectors are impacted differently by rate movements

    • Generally speaking, companies with staple-like characteristics—slow growth but very stable earnings—are impacted the least by changes in interest rates.

    • Growth stocks are impacted a lot, again because of the DCF mechanism.

    • A growth stock, especially a hyper-growth story, has potentially big earnings in the outer years.

    • In DCF, when the numbers get big in the outer years, changes in the discount rate impact the valuation number a lot.

    • So generally, when rates go up or are going up:

      • Growth stocks will go down the most.

      • Staples will go down the least, and staples could even go up as people reallocate.

  15. Why stocks go up when rates go down

    • As for why stocks go up when rates go down: just reverse everything he just said.

  16. Transition

    • That concludes his explanation of interest rates and stocks in the master class.

No comments: