Stock Selling Strategies: The Buy and Hold Strategy

Stock Selling Strategies
The Buy and Hold Strategy

The selling strategy of what is commonly called the buy and hold approach to investing can be expressed in one word - don't! And the arguments in its favour are strong ones. For one, it has a solid record of success. Such famous names as Warren Buffett and John Templeton made their fortunes with it.

Or consider the remarkable case of Anne Scheiber. She represents, not only the superb returns that can be enjoyed from a skillful buy and hold strategy, but also the pluck to jump back in the game after losing everything.

In 1933 and 1934, at the height of the depression, 38 year old Anne invested most of her life savings in the stock market. She let her broker brother make the picks and they were good ones. Unfortunately, his company went bankrupt and she lost everything. But Anne did not give up.

On her modest salary as an auditor for the Internal Revenue Service (just over $3000 a year), she managed to save another $5000 over the next ten years. In 1944 she invested in the stock market again. When she died in January 1995 at the age of 101, that modest investment had grown to $20 million. That's not a misprint. $20 million! That represents an annual compounded rate of return of 17.5%, ranking her among the top investors of all time.

Her secret? Miss Scheiber invested in stocks of companies that she knew and understood. Companies whose products she used. She loved the movies. So she invested in Loew's, Columbia, Paramount and Capital Cities Broadcasting. She drank Coke and Pepsi and bought shares in both. She invested in the companies that made medications she took - Schering Plough and Bristol Myers Squibb. And so on. And she hung on to them through thick and thin for over forty years. Through the bear market of 1973-1974. Through the crash of 1987.

Miss Scheiber left virtually the entire fortune to New York's Yeshiva University. By the time the estate was settled in December of 1995, it had grown to $22 million. You'll find links to her story and to investing tips based on her approach after this article.

The Buy and Hold approach to investing focuses on the buying, not the selling. The aim is to buy stock in companies that are solid and growing with long term potential. It focuses on the underlying value of the stock.

The approach is often considered synonymous with value investing. It ignores the stock market, the general economic climate, and prevailing sentiment.

Warren Buffett, considered by many to be the greatest investor of all time, has said that he pays no attention to the stock market, and in fact, would not mind if the market shut down for a few years. He buys stock in a company as if he was buying the entire company. It's the value of the company that interests him, not the value assigned to it by the market. He wants companies that generate consistently growing profits.

Value investors tend to focus on buying undervalued stocks. And value investing is not completely averse to selling a stock, though the preference is to hold. As the Templeton Fund puts at their website, "Templeton buys stocks with the intent to hold them until they reach their "fair" value-- typically five years."

Buy and hold investors do sell when the fundamentals of a company change or when a stock becomes so grossly over-valued by the market that it would be foolish not to take profits. But in general, short term market fluctuations are ignored.

Downside to Buy and Hold

Of course, while buy and hold investing has definite advantages, there is a downside.

There have been major bear markets in the past and such markets tend to drag down all stocks, even those of good companies. If such risks can be minimized, wouldn't it be worth it?

The question is, can it? In the June 19, 2000 issue of the Hulbert Financial Digest, Mark Hulbert points out that there are newsletters who have been able to minimize investor losses during severe market corrections. Five in particular stand out. These five market timers were able to keep their readers' losses to one or two percent during each of the last five major market corrections since August 1987 (while the Wilshire 5000 averaged a 15% loss and the NASDAQ Composite lost 20%).

But...and here's the rub - those five newsletters failed to capture the tremendous gains made during the up cycles. Their average returns for the entire period from August 31, 1987 to May 31, 2000 ranged from 2.3% to 7.2% while the Wilshire averaged 14.3% and the NASDAQ 17.1%. Safety comes at a serious price!

In fact, Buy and Holders disparage the notion of market timing. It is folly, they say. And a pamphlet from the Templeton Fund in 1997 demonstrates that better than anything. Follow the link below for a summary.

The Folly of Market Timing

Summary of Advantages and Disadvantages
of the Buy and Hold Strategy

Advantages	Disadvantages
Don't have to worry about the market.	Doesn't protect against bear markets and corrections.
Don't have to worry about the economy.	Stocks should be extensively researched and carefully chosen.
Don't have to pay attention to short term fluctuations.	Long term strategy.
Easy to manage portfolio.	No quick short term profits.
Ideally, don't have to sell at all.
Notable success stories and history.

http://breakoutreport.com/investingcanada/library/weekly/2000a/aa062900.htm