Warren Buffett Intrinsic Value Calculator - Determine if Stock is Undervalued or Not.

Warren Buffett's 4 Rules:
1.  Vigilant Leaders
2.  Long Term Prospects
3.  Stock Stability
4.  Undervalued

Non-Predictable Company (Andrew :-) )

1. Lots of Debt
2. No Long Term Prospects
3. Not Stable
4. Price ? - Can't be determined due to stability

Predictable Company (Linda :-) )

1. Manageable Debt
2. Long-term Prospects
3. Stable 
4. Market Price = $44.33  Intrinsic Value = ?

Lesson Objective 1: How do we calculate the intrinsic value of a stock

Lesson Objective 2: How do we use the BuffettsBooks.com intrinsic value calculator

Summary of this lesson

In this lesson, students learned that the intrinsic value can be defined as the discounted value of the cash that can be taken out of a business during it's remaining life. For us, we've defined the life as the next ten years. This way, we can discount that cash by the 10 year federal note. The Cash that we are taking out of the business is simply the dividends and the book value growth during the next 10 years. Since these numbers need to be estimated, it's very important to ensure that Warren Buffett's third rule (a stock must be stable and understandable) is met.

When a company doesn't have a history of linear growth, estimating the cash that they will produce for the next ten years becomes more speculative. When we look at the root of the intrinsic value calculator, it operates off of the same principals as a bond calculator. Instead of using coupons, we substitute dividends. And instead of using par value (or value at maturity) we estimate the book value of the business in 10 years. The value that we use to discount the summation of the cash is simply the 10 year federal note.

Although the previous paragraph might sound confusing to some, it's application is fairly straight forward. The reason Buffett says, "Two people looking at the same set of facts, will almost inevitably come up with at least slightly different intrinsic value figures," is due to a difference in opinion of the future cash flows. Since some investors are more conservative than others, their estimates of book value growth or dividend payments may be lower. This will immediately change the intrinsic value. Your job as an intelligent investor is to determine your own tolerance for risk and conservative estimates on how much money you will receive while owning the stock for a 10 year period.

Intrinsic Value Calculator

Source of Quotes: http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/owners.html

"Intrinsic value can be defined simply: It is the discounted value of the cash that can be taken out of a business during its remaining life." - Warren Buffett

Therefore, the sum of cash that can be taken out of the business over the next ten years is going to be the dividends plus the equity growth. The discounted value is the current value of the 10 year federal note. To start, we'll determine how much a company's book value is growing.

"In other words, the percentage change in book value in any given year is likely to be reasonably close to that year's change in intrinsic value."- Warren Buffett

Click here for the Intrinsic Value Calculator:  

http://www.buffettsbooks.com/intelligent-investor/stocks/intrinsic-value-calculator.html

Related:

Would you rather be with Andrew or Linda? Businesses manage their finances just like individual people. :-)

INTRINSIC VALUE: THE RIGHT PRICE TO PAY

INTRINSIC VALUE

Both Warren Buffett and Benjamin Graham talk about the intrinsic value of a business, or a share in it.  That is, to buy a business, or a share in it, at a fair price. 

But, having regard to the possibility of error in calculating intrinsic value, the careful of investor should provide a margin of error by only buying the business, or shares, at a substantial discount to the intrinsic value.

Buffett is said to look for a 25 per cent discount, but who really knows?

DEFINING INTRINSIC VALUE

Buffett’s concept, in looking at intrinsic value, is that it values what can be taken out of the business. 

He has quoted investment guru John Burr Williams who defined value like this:

‘The value of any stock, bond or business today is determined by the cash inflows and outflows – discounted at an appropriate interest rate – that can be expected to occur during the remaining life of the asset.’ – The Theory of Investment Value.

The difference for Buffett in calculating the value of bonds and shares is that the investor knows the eventual price of the bond when it matures but has to guess the price of the share at some future date.

Warren Buffett's Secret "Value" Formula

Warren Buffett Value Formula separates weak industries from strong ones.




Warren Buffett's Secret "Value" Formula




Which Industries Does Warren Buffett Avoid?

Graham's Intrinsic Value Formula

Graham did create a very useful and easy-to-use intrinsic value formula.

Graham's formula: You take a current earnings, apply a base P/E ratio, add a growth factor if there is a growth, and adjust according to current bond yield. The result is an intrinsic value that the stock can be expected to achieve in the real world if growth targets are met.

Formula: Intrinsic value = E x (2g + 8.5) x 4.4/Y

E = current annual earnings per share
g = annual earnings growth rate. (Graham would have suggested using a conservative number for growth.)
8.5 = base P/E ratio for a stock with no growth
Y = current interest rate, represented as the average rate on high-grade corporate bonds. (Note that lower bond rates make the intrinsic value higher, as future earnings streams are worth more in a lower interest rate environment.)

Take Hewlett Packard as an example. With current earnings (trailing 12 months) of $2.30 per share, a growth rate of 10%, and a corporate bond interest rate of 6%, the intrinsic value is

= $2.30 x [(2 x 10) + 8.5] x (4.4/6)
= $48.07 per share

This value almost exactly matches the price at the time that these calculations were made. That suggests little potential price appreciation in the stock - unless per share earnings growth accelerates or bond yields dip.

Acceleration in the business would increase the earnings growth rate, and share repurchases would increase the earnings per share. Both changes, especially taken together, would stimulate growth in intrinsic value.

You shouldn't go out and buy or sell stock based on this formula alone, of course, but it's a great "quick" test of a stock's price and true value.