Wilmar: Asia’s next Cargill in China?

Wilmar: Asia’s next Cargill in China?


KUALA LUMPUR, May 3 — Singapore-listed Wilmar is shaping up to become the Asian version of agribusiness giant Cargill, with an expanding network of farms, food processors and shipping companies.

And it’s showing its muscle where it matters most — in China.

Wilmar’s integrated China operations account for 44.7 per cent of its US$10.3 billion (RM32.79 billion) assets, allowing it to weather recent volatile food prices and now a likely yuan policy change.

The company had the most to gain when Beijing in April slapped import curbs on Argentine soyoil — a commodity that competes with Wilmar’s domestically crushed oilseeds in China and imported palm oil.

This resilience has spurred investors to clamour for Wilmar to revisit a shelved IPO for its China business, possibly this year, four years after the powerful Kuok family merged Wilmar and Malaysia-based Kuok Group to create the US$32 billion firm.

“I believe they will revisit the IPO. It’s anybody’s guess when it happens, but Wilmar has rightly tapped into the fact that agriculture is super-hot in China,” said Michael Greenall, an analyst with BNP Paribas.

“With the super-charged growth in China’s economy, higher incomes and rural-to-urban migration contributing to stronger demand in all the sectors it’s invested in, Wilmar will act.”

Wilmar’s proposed China listing would have raised as much as US$3.5 billion on the Hong Kong stock exchange, at the lower end of the range of China-based food companies.

Wilmar, which has been dubbed by analysts as the “China proxy”, currently trades at 18 times its 2010 earnings, richer than rival China Agri Industries’ 14 times but cheaper than 22 times at China Foods.

Wilmar’s shares have gained more than 8 per cent this year, outperforming a 2.5 per cent rise on Singapore’s benchmark index, while other plantation firms such as Malaysia’s Sime Darby, IOI Group and Indonesia’s Astra Agro Lestari are trading lower.

Margins in Wilmar’s main business sectors — oilseeds and grains, palm and laurics and consumer food products — certainly have room to grow as the world’s most populous country and third-largest economy keeps to its target of 8 per cent annual growth.

YUAN BOOST?

An immediate margin boost may come from a yuan policy shift that could make imported soybeans cheaper for Wilmar — a top importer that dominates a fifth of China’s 94 million tonnes of soy processing capacity.

It also buffers Wilmar from negative margins arising from weak livestock feed demand for soymeal, as the food processor can channel soyoil into its cooking oil business that controls 45 per cent of China’s market.

In contrast, the influx of cheap soy imports may further weigh on smaller crushers that have tiny integrated downstream operations. Some have none to speak of.

Soyoil accounts for a quarter of China’s 6.4 million tonnes of edible oil imports, and Wilmar makes up the rest with palm oil from its estates in Southeast Asia, taking a larger market share than Sime and IOI.

Analysts say a Wilmar IPO will bring all these factors into play.


“Wilmar is one of its kind. They are not only selling to China but they also know the supply side (because) they have estates in Malaysian and Indonesia,” said Ivy Ng, an analyst with Malaysia’s CIMB Investment Bank.

“If you look at China Agri, they don’t have any estates, they buy palm, process and sell.”

Wilmar’s plantation landbank of 570,000 hectares is just 41 per cent planted, and analysts say the planting will rise in tandem with China’s growing appetite for edible oils and palm oil getting cheaper if Beijing lets its currency appreciate.

The scale of its operations — 130 processors and plants in China — allows Wilmar to manage the fluctuations in soybeans and palm oil and preserve earnings.

A 10 per cent change in the price of palm oil only affects the company’s 2010 earnings by 2 per cent, Goldman Sachs said in a note. Other analysts say such a swing affects earnings of purer plantation plays such as Astra Agro Lestari by 13 per cent.

TURNING TO RICE AND WHEAT

The major risk to Wilmar’s growth is that it will eventually come up against regulations stipulating that foreign firms cannot own new soy processors and those with a soy market share of more than 15 per cent will not get approval to expand capacity.

But analysts are still pricing in an upside to Wilmar’s share price, which surged 130 per cent in 2009. The Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S survey of 19 analysts has an average target price for Wilmar of S$7.80 (RM18.13) — a 13 per cent gain from its current level.

Much of the optimism lies with Wilmar’s aggressive move into China’s highly fragmented rice and wheat milling sectors, which are the world’s largest, and also produce noodles and pastries.

“They have been investing a lot in rice and flour in China, which can become very big,” Nomura analyst Tanuj Shori said.

“The biggest entry barrier is scale. The bigger you are, the easier it is to achieve higher profitability.”

China Agri leads with a 2 per cent market share in both sectors, but Wilmar can take top position as it can build mills at its existing manufacturing bases where it can share overheads and logistics, reducing costs and boosting margins, analysts say.

Backed by a balance sheet of US$23.5 billion, Wilmar can fund its rice and wheat expansion through its US$1 billion capex. China Agri plans to spend US$1.1 billion this year.

And Wilmar can channel wheat and rice products to its existing edible oil customers — noodle manufacturers Tingyi and Want Want.

“We believe Wilmar is capable of adding 4 million tonnes,” said Hwang-DBS analyst Ben Santoso, basing that on five 400,000 tonne capacity plants for both rice and flour.

“Compared to its last published capacity of 890,000 tonnes, it’s an extraordinary expansion.” — Reuters

Wilmar delays China IPO, to invest in Africa

Wilmar delays China IPO, to invest in Africa
Published: 2009/11/13

SINGAPORE: Wilmar International, the world's largest listed palm oil firm, signalled a promising outlook for its earnings but said the US$3.5 billion (US$1 = RM3.38) listing of its China unit is on hold due to its concern over valuations.

The palm oil giant's listing plan was the recent trigger for a rally in its shares, which retreated yesterday despite a quarterly profit that beat expectations.

"We will shelve it for the time being and wait for market conditions to improve," Wilmar's chairman and CEO Kuok Khoon Hong said after a media and analysts' briefing for its third-quarter results.

"We only will list the China operation if it commands better price than what Wilmar is commanding right now in the stock market," he added.

Analysts have estimated that Wilmar's China unit could be valued as by much as 20 times earnings, matching the parent company's current price-to-earnings multiple.

With more than 30 firms eyeing listings in either Hong Kong or India over the next few months, leading to more than US$10 billion in share sales, companies wanting to list have had to keep their hopes for high prices in check.

Analysts have said Wilmar, which has a market value of US$30 billion, has no immediate need for funds.

The company said it was optimistic about prospects for the rest of this year after a one-off gain helped it post a better-than-expected 35 per cent rise in its third quarter profit.

Analysts were less impressed. "Excluding exceptional and one-off items, Wilmar's operating performance in its third quarter 2009 was not as strong as we would expect from normal seasonality," Goldman Sachs analyst Patrick Tiah said in a research note.

"Notwithstanding, given the market's low expectations we believe consensus earnings could rise following the results," he added.

Wilmar's Kuok said the company plans to invest at least US$1 billion in China, Indonesia and Africa to expand its plantations and plants.

The company has raised profits in the last few quarters thanks to its processing and refining capabilities, outperforming rival palm oil firms that depend primarily on plantations.

Wilmar's shares have more than doubled this year, but some analysts cut their ratings after the company delayed plans in late September to float its China unit due to volatile markets.

The listing would have raised around US$3.5 billion.

CEO Kuok said earlier in a statement that he was optimistic about the firm's prospects for the rest of the financial year given the diversity of its business segments.

Wilmar, derives about half of its total sales from China, and owns oil palm plantations and runs crushing and refining plants in Indonesia and Malaysia.

The company, the second-largest on the Singapore Exchange after Singapore Telecommunications, earned US$653 million in July-September, up from US $483 million a year ago. - Reuters

PPB may use sugar proceeds to invest in Wilmar China

PPB may use sugar proceeds to invest in Wilmar China

Tags: HKEX | OSK Research | PPB Group Bhd | Wilmar China | Wilmar International

Written by Melody Song
Tuesday, 03 November 2009 11:17

KUALA LUMPUR: PPB GROUP BHD [] may utilise the RM1.29 billion proceeds from the sale of its sugar refining and trading business in Malaysia, to subscribe for shares in Wilmar China, according to OSK Research.

The research firm believes that by investing in Wilmar China, which is planning an initial public offering (IPO) on the Hong Kong Exchange (HKEX), PPB will get “a bigger bang for the buck”, compared to buying additional shares in Wilmar International Ltd.

PPB had in an announcement last Friday said it would channel the proceeds to make strategic investments rather than distribute them as special dividends to shareholders.

The announcement was pertaining to PPB’s proposed divestment to Felda Global Ventures Holdings Sdn Bhd of all its sugar refining and trading business in Malaysia, comprising a 100% stake in Malayan Sugar Manufacturing Sdn Bhd, 50% stake in Kilang Gula Felda Perlis Sdn Bhd and 5,797ha of land in Perlis, for a total consideration of RM1.29 billion.

According to OSK, PPB currently owns 18.22% stake in Wilmar International, which is planning to float its China operation under Wilmar China on the HKEX.

“If PPB were to raise its investment in Wilmar International, it would only be able to buy an additional 1.3% based on the current price,” said OSK in a note yesterday, citing that PPB’s chairman had mentioned the group would only raise stakes in Wilmar International if the price were right.

“We doubt that the proceeds would be used to buy into Wilmar International given that the additional stake (of 1.3%) will only raise PPB’s pre-tax profit by RM59.5 million (based on our estimates) compared to about RM165 million (in pre-tax profits) forgone from its sugar refining and trading business. Moreover, PPB is already equity-accounting Wilmar International’s contribution,” noted OSK.

Hence, the research firm believed that the company would rather invest the proceeds to subscribe for the IPO shares of Wilmar China.

OSK said PPB’s 18.22% stake in Wilmar International is worth RM17.86 billion compared to its own market capitalisation of RM17.95 billion.

“Assuming zero value for its other businesses, PPB’s revised net asset value (RNAV) is estimated at RM19.29 billion, taking into consideration its net cash of RM140.96 million and the sale proceeds of RM1.29 billion. Hence PPB is trading at a narrow 7% discount to its RNAV,” said OSK.

PPB closed 20 sen or 1.32% higher at RM15.34 yesterday.


This article appeared in The Edge Financial Daily, November 3, 2009.